Colin D. Bruzewicz

Remote entanglement need not be the bottleneck for modular trapped-ion quantum computing

Felix W. Knollmann, David P. Nadlinger, John Blue, Sabrina M. Corsetti, Sam J. Bishop, Adam R. Martinez, Jelena Notaros, Colin D. Bruzewicz, Robert McConnell, Isaac L. Chuang

Abstract

Modularity underpins classical computing; as quantum processors encounter limits on fabrication yield, reliability, and size, they will also need it acutely. The bottleneck to linking modules is producing shared entanglement at sufficient rate, density, and fidelity. Trapped ions hold the best demonstrated photonic links, yet they rely on bulky collection optics that cap how densely links can be packed, and remote entanglement operations trail local gates by two orders of magnitude in rate and fidelity. We synthesize several enabling results $\unicode{x2014}$ single-photon heralding, coherent recoil correction, projective distillation, and trap-integrated photonics $\unicode{x2014}$ into one comprehensive architecture that substantially narrows this gap. Single-photon heralding leads to linear scaling of success probability with detection efficiency, allowing compact integrated photonics to saturate the entanglement rate at a local-operation limit in dense, easy-to-parallelize channels. Addressing its inherent error mechanisms at their source, we project a Bell-pair fidelity of 99.9% at rates and densities compatible with fault-tolerant operations. Remote entanglement then need not remain the bottleneck for modular trapped-ion computing; the limit shifts to the local operations that must improve regardless.

Real-time magnetic field noise correction using trapped-ion monitor qubits

Kyle DeBry [1,2], Agustin Valdes-Martinez [1,2], David Reens [2], Colin D. Bruzewicz [2], John Chiaverini [1,2]

Abstract

We demonstrate a trapped-ion protocol in which a nearby, dedicated "monitor" qubit tracks magnetic-field drifts in real time without interrupting data-qubit operations. Using two $^{40}\mathrm{Ca}^+$ ions and the optical--metastable--ground architecture, we encode the data qubit in the ground-state manifold and the monitor qubit in a metastable-state manifold to achieve spectral separation. The monitor qubit senses common magnetic fluctuations during data-qubit experiments, enabling feedforward corrections to the qubit-control drives. Under applied magnetic noise with a realistic spectrum ($1/f^{2}$), the protocol maintains coherence and, when compared with interleaved calibration, it extends usable data-qubit probe times by up to a factor of ${\sim}\sqrt{2}$ and doubles the experimental duty cycle. These results establish monitor qubits as a scalable tool for real-time recalibration in quantum information processors.

Collection of fluorescence from an ion using trap-integrated photonics

Felix W. Knollmann [1], Sabrina M. Corsetti [1], Ethan R. Clements [1], Reuel Swint [2], Aaron D. Leu [1,3], May E. Kim [2], Patrick T. Callahan [2], Dave Kharas [2], Thomas Mahony [2], Cheryl Sorace-Agaskar [2], Robert McConnell [2], Colin D. Bruzewicz [2], Isaac L. Chuang [1], Jelena Notaros [1], John Chiaverini [1,2]

Abstract

Spontaneously emitted photons are entangled with the electronic and nuclear degrees of freedom of the emitting atom, so interference and measurement of these photons can entangle separate matter-based quantum systems as a resource for quantum information processing. However, the isotropic nature of spontaneous emission hinders the single-mode photonic operations required to generate entanglement. Current demonstrations rely on bulk photon-collection and manipulation optics that suffer from environment-induced phase instability, mode matching challenges, and system-to-system variability, factors that impede scaling to the large numbers of entangled pairs needed for quantum information processing. To address these limitations, we demonstrate a collection method that enables passive phase stability, straightforward photonic manipulation, and intrinsic reproducibility. Specifically, we engineer a waveguide-integrated grating to couple photons emitted from a trapped ion into a single optical mode within a microfabricated ion-trap chip. Using the integrated collection optic, we characterize the collection efficiency, image the ion, and detect the ion's quantum state. This proof-of-principle demonstration lays the foundation for leveraging the inherent stability and reproducibility of integrated photonics to efficiently create, manipulate, and measure multipartite quantum states in arrays of quantum emitters.

Integrated-Photonics-Based Systems for Polarization-Gradient Cooling of Trapped Ions

Sabrina M. Corsetti [1], Ashton Hattori [1], Ethan R. Clements [1], Felix W. Knollmann [1], Milica Notaros [1], Reuel Swint [2], Tal Sneh [1], Patrick T. Callahan [2], Gavin N. West [1], Dave Kharas [2], Thomas Mahony [2], Colin D. Bruzewicz [2], Cheryl Sorace-Agaskar [2], Robert McConnell [2], Isaac L. Chuang [1], John Chiaverini [1,2], Jelena Notaros [1]

Abstract

Trapped ions are a promising modality for quantum systems, with demonstrated utility as the basis for quantum processors and optical clocks. However, traditional trapped-ion systems are implemented using complex free-space optical configurations, whose large size and susceptibility to vibrations and drift inhibit scaling to large numbers of qubits. In recent years, integrated-photonics-based systems have been demonstrated as an avenue to address the challenge of scaling trapped-ion systems while maintaining high fidelities. While these previous demonstrations have implemented both Doppler and resolved-sideband cooling of trapped ions, these cooling techniques are fundamentally limited in efficiency. In contrast, polarization-gradient cooling can enable faster and more power-efficient cooling and, therefore, improved computational efficiencies in trapped-ion systems. While free-space implementations of polarization-gradient cooling have demonstrated advantages over other cooling mechanisms, polarization-gradient cooling has never previously been implemented using integrated photonics. In this paper, we design and experimentally demonstrate key polarization-diverse integrated-photonics devices and utilize them to implement a variety of integrated-photonics-based polarization-gradient-cooling systems, culminating in the first experimental demonstration of polarization-gradient cooling of a trapped ion by an integrated-photonics-based system. By demonstrating polarization-gradient cooling using an integrated-photonics-based system and, in general, opening up the field of polarization-diverse integrated-photonics-based devices and systems for trapped ions, this work facilitates new capabilities for integrated-photonics-based trapped-ion platforms.

Sub-Doppler cooling of a trapped ion in a phase-stable polarization gradient

Ethan Clements [1], Felix W. Knollmann [1], Sabrina Corsetti [1], Zhaoyi Li [1], Ashton Hattori [1], Milica Notaros [1], Reuel Swint [2], Tal Sneh [1], May E. Kim [2], Aaron D. Leu [3], Patrick Callahan [2], Thomas Mahony [2], Gavin N. West [1], Cheryl Sorace-Agaskar [2], Dave Kharas [2], Robert McConnell [2], Colin D. Bruzewicz [2], Isaac L. Chuang [1], Jelena Notaros [1], John Chiaverini [1,2]

Abstract

Trapped ions provide a highly controlled platform for quantum sensors, clocks, simulators, and computers, all of which depend on cooling ions close to their motional ground state. Existing methods like Doppler, resolved sideband, and dark resonance cooling balance trade-offs between the final temperature and cooling rate. A traveling polarization gradient has been shown to cool multiple modes quickly and in parallel, but utilizing a stable polarization gradient can achieve lower ion energies, while also allowing more tailorable light-matter interactions in general. In this paper, we demonstrate cooling of a trapped ion below the Doppler limit using a phase-stable polarization gradient created using trap-integrated photonic devices. At an axial frequency of $2π\cdot1.45~ \rm MHz$ we achieve $\langle n \rangle = 1.3 \pm 1.1$ in $500~μ\rm s$ and cooling rates of ${\sim}0.3 \, \rm quanta/μs$. We examine ion dynamics under different polarization gradient phases, detunings, and intensities, showing reasonable agreement between experimental results and a simple model. Cooling is fast and power-efficient, with improved performance compared to simulated operation under the corresponding running wave configuration.

Experimental quantum channel discrimination using metastable states of a trapped ion

Kyle DeBry [1,2], Jasmine Sinanan-Singh [1], Colin D. Bruzewicz [2], David Reens [2], May E. Kim [2], Matthew P. Roychowdhury [2], Robert McConnell [2], Isaac L. Chuang [1], John Chiaverini [2,3]

Abstract

We present experimental demonstrations of accurate and unambiguous single-shot discrimination between three quantum channels using a single trapped $^{40}\text{Ca}^{+}$ ion. The three channels cannot be distinguished unambiguously using repeated single channel queries, the natural classical analogue. We develop techniques for using the 6-dimensional $\text{D}_{5/2}$ state space for quantum information processing, and we implement protocols to discriminate quantum channel analogues of phase shift keying and amplitude shift keying data encodings used in classical radio communication. The demonstrations achieve discrimination accuracy exceeding $99\%$ in each case, limited entirely by known experimental imperfections.

High-Fidelity Ion State Detection Using Trap-Integrated Avalanche Photodiodes

David Reens [1], Michael Collins [1], Joseph Ciampi [1], Dave Kharas [1], Brian F. Aull [1], Kevan Donlon [1], Colin D. Bruzewicz [1], Bradley Felton [1], Jules Stuart [1,2], Robert J. Niffenegger [1], Philip Rich [1,2], Danielle Braje [1], Kevin K. Ryu [1], John Chiaverini [1,2], Robert McConnell [1]

Abstract

Integrated technologies greatly enhance the prospects for practical quantum information processing and sensing devices based on trapped ions. High-speed and high-fidelity ion state readout is critical for any such application. Integrated detectors offer significant advantages for system portability and can also greatly facilitate parallel operations if a separate detector can be incorporated at each ion-trapping location. Here we demonstrate ion quantum state detection at room temperature utilizing single-photon avalanche diodes (SPADs) integrated directly into the substrate of silicon ion trapping chips. We detect the state of a trapped $^{88}\text{Sr}^{+}$ ion via fluorescence collection with the SPAD, achieving $99.92(1)\%$ average fidelity in 450 $μ$s, opening the door to the application of integrated state detection to quantum computing and sensing utilizing arrays of trapped ions.

Integrated multi-wavelength control of an ion qubit

Robert J. Niffenegger, Jules Stuart, Cheryl Sorace-Agaskar, Dave Kharas, Suraj Bramhavar, Colin D. Bruzewicz, William Loh, Ryan T. Maxson, Robert McConnell, David Reens, Gavin N. West, Jeremy M. Sage, John Chiaverini

Abstract

Monolithic integration of control technologies for atomic systems is a promising route to the development of quantum computers and portable quantum sensors. Trapped atomic ions form the basis of high-fidelity quantum information processors and high-accuracy optical clocks. However, current implementations rely on free-space optics for ion control, which limits their portability and scalability. Here we demonstrate a surface-electrode ion-trap chip using integrated waveguides and grating couplers, which delivers all the wavelengths of light required for ionization, cooling, coherent operations, and quantum-state preparation and detection of Sr+ qubits. Laser light from violet to infrared is coupled onto the chip via an optical-fiber array, creating an inherently stable optical path, which we use to demonstrate qubit coherence that is resilient to platform vibrations. This demonstration of CMOS-compatible integrated-photonic surface-trap fabrication, robust packaging, and enhanced qubit coherence is a key advance in the development of portable trapped-ion quantum sensors and clocks, providing a way toward the complete, individual control of larger numbers of ions in quantum information processing systems.

Trapped-Ion Quantum Computing: Progress and Challenges

Colin D. Bruzewicz [1], John Chiaverini [1], Robert McConnell [1], Jeremy M. Sage [1]

Abstract

Trapped ions are among the most promising systems for practical quantum computing (QC). The basic requirements for universal QC have all been demonstrated with ions and quantum algorithms using few-ion-qubit systems have been implemented. We review the state of the field, covering the basics of how trapped ions are used for QC and their strengths and limitations as qubits. In addition, we discuss what is being done, and what may be required, to increase the scale of trapped ion quantum computers while mitigating decoherence and control errors. Finally, we explore the outlook for trapped-ion QC. In particular, we discuss near-term applications, considerations impacting the design of future systems of trapped ions, and experiments and demonstrations that may further inform these considerations.

Heisenberg scaling of imaging resolution by coherent enhancement

Robert McConnell [1], Guang Hao Low [2], Theodore J. Yoder [2], Colin D. Bruzewicz [1], Isaac L. Chuang [2], John Chiaverini [1], Jeremy M. Sage [1]

Abstract

Classical imaging works by scattering photons from an object to be imaged, and achieves resolution scaling as $1/\sqrt{t}$, with $t$ the imaging time. By contrast, the laws of quantum mechanics allow one to utilize quantum coherence to obtain imaging resolution that can scale as quickly as $1/t$ -- the so-called "Heisenberg limit." However, ambiguities in the obtained signal often preclude taking full advantage of this quantum enhancement, while imaging techniques designed to be unambiguous often lose this optimal Heisenberg scaling. Here, we demonstrate an imaging technique which combines unambiguous detection of the target with Heisenberg scaling of the resolution. We also demonstrate a binary search algorithm which can efficiently locate a coherent target using the technique, resolving a target trapped ion to within 0.3% of the $1/e^2$ diameter of the excitation beam.

Integrated optical addressing of an ion qubit

Karan K. Mehta [1], Colin D. Bruzewicz [2], Robert McConnell [2], Rajeev J. Ram [1], Jeremy M. Sage [2], John Chiaverini [2]

Abstract

The long coherence times and strong Coulomb interactions afforded by trapped ion qubits have enabled realizations of the necessary primitives for quantum information processing (QIP), and indeed the highest-fidelity quantum operations in any qubit to date. But while light delivery to each individual ion in a system is essential for general quantum manipulations and readout, experiments so far have employed optical systems cumbersome to scale to even a few tens of qubits. Here we demonstrate lithographically defined nanophotonic waveguide devices for light routing and ion addressing fully integrated within a surface-electrode ion trap chip. Ion qubits are addressed at multiple locations via focusing grating couplers emitting through openings in the trap electrodes to ions trapped 50 $μ$m above the chip; using this light we perform quantum coherent operations on the optical qubit transition in individual $^{88}$Sr$^+$ ions. The grating focuses the beam to a diffraction-limited spot near the ion position with a 2 $μ$m 1/$e^2$-radius along the trap axis, and we measure crosstalk errors between $10^{-2}$ and $4\times10^{-4}$ at distances 7.5-15 $μ$m from the beam center. Owing to the scalability of the planar fabrication employed, together with the tight focusing and stable alignment afforded by optics integration within the trap chip, this approach presents a path to creating the optical systems required for large-scale trapped-ion QIP.