Yotam Shapira

Trapped-Ion Multiqubit Gates are Compatible with Scalable Quantum Error Correction

Ori Grossman [1], Yotam Kadish [1], Snir Gazit [1], Amit Ben-Kish [1], Roee Ozeri [1,2], Yotam Shapira [1]

Abstract

We construct a detailed microscopic noise model for multi-qubit (MQ) gate operations in the context of trapped ion architecture with all-to-all connectivity. We find that phonon heating and motional dephasing are well captured by effective single- and two-qubit error channels that can, in principle, act between arbitrary pairs of qubits. Nevertheless, the median magnitude of two-qubit errors between uncoupled qubits is substantially smaller than that of errors between gate-coupled qubits. Errors associated with photon scattering are shown to solely propagate to qubits participating in gate operations. Lastly, we combine all noise sources, assigned with experimentally relevant parameters, and explore the scalability of a quantum error correction (QEC) scheme based on the rotated surface code, as a function of error rates and code size. Our analysis bridges device-level physics and QEC performance for MQ gates in trapped-ion architectures.

Digital Predistortion of Optical Fields for Fast and High-Fidelity Entangling Gates in Trapped-Ion Qubits

Jovan Markov [1], Yotam Shapira [2], Ayelet Hasson [1], Meir Alon [1], Avraham Gross [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Roee Ozeri [1,2]

Abstract

High-fidelity quantum gates require precise classical control signals, yet the analog hardware delivering these signals introduces nonlinear distortions that degrade gate performance. We demonstrate digital predistortion of an acousto-optic modulator used to generate multi-tone entangling-gate waveforms in a trapped-ion processor based on $^{88}$Sr$^+$. By measuring and inverting the static nonlinear amplitude response of the modulator, we apply a feed-forward correction that extends its linear operating range and suppresses spurious intermodulation products. Spectral analysis of the gate beam shows 3--5 dB suppression of the dominant intermodulation tones, approximately doubling the usable diffraction efficiency at a $10^{-3}$ estimated gate-error threshold. Direct two-qubit Bell-state fidelity measurements confirm that predistortion consistently improves entangling-gate performance. The calibrate-and-invert methodology is device and platform agnostic, applicable to any nonlinear element in the classical control chain of a quantum processor.

Optimal constant-cost implementations of Clifford operations using global interactions

Jonathan Nemirovsky [1], Lee Peleg [1], Amit Ben Kish [1], Yotam Shapira [1]

Abstract

We investigate quantum circuits built from arbitrary single-qubit operations combined with programmable all-to-all multiqubit entangling gates that are native to, among other systems, trapped-ion quantum computing platforms. We report a constant-cost of no more than four applications of such Clifford entangling multiqubit gates to realize any sequence of Clifford operations of any length, without ancillae, which is the theoretically optimal gate count cost. We do this by implementing any sequence of CNOT gates of any length with four applications of such gates, without ancillae, and show that the extension to general Clifford operations incurs no additional cost. We investigate the required qubit drive power that is associated with our implementation and show that it is lower than that of a standard approach. Our work introduces a practical and computationally efficient algorithm to realize these compilations.

Phase gadget compilation of quantum circuits using multiqubit gates

Jonathan Nemirovsky [1], Maya Chuchem [1], Lee Peleg [1], Yakov Solomons [1], Amit Ben Kish [1], Yotam Shapira [1]

Abstract

Quantum circuit synthesis and compilation are critical components in the quantum computing stack, both for contemporary quantum systems, where efficient use of limited resources is essential, as well as for large-scale fault-tolerant platforms, where computation time can be minimized. The specific characteristics of the quantum hardware determine which circuit designs and optimizations are feasible. We present a phase-gadget based method for compilation of quantum circuits using programmable multiqubit entangling gates, that are native, among others, to trapped-ions quantum computers. We use phase-gadgets in order to generically reduce circuit depths and efficiently implement them with few, high-fidelity, multiqubit gates. We test our methods on a large set of benchmark circuits and demonstrate generic circuit depth reduction and implementation error reduction.

Reduced constant-cost implementations of Clifford operations using global interactions

Jonathan Nemirovsky [1], Lee Peleg [1], Amit Ben Kish [1], Yotam Shapira [1]

Abstract

We investigate quantum circuits built from arbitrary single-qubit operations combined with programmable all-to-all multiqubit entangling gates that are native to, among other systems, trapped-ion quantum computing platforms. We report a constant-cost of no more than 6 application of such Clifford entangling multiqubit gates to realize any sequence of Clifford operations of any length, without ancillae. Furthermore, we show that any sequence of CNOT gates of any length, can be replaced with 5 applications of such Clifford entangling multiqubit gates, without ancillae. We investigate the required qubit drive power that is associated with these implementations. Our work introduces a practical and computationally efficient algorithm to realize these compilations.

Full programmable quantum computing with trapped-ions using semi-global fields

Yakov Solomons [1], Yotam Kadish [1], Lee Peleg [1], Jonathan Nemirovsky [1], Amit Ben Kish [1], Yotam Shapira [1]

Abstract

Trapped-ion quantum computing can utilize all motional modes of the ion-crystal, to entangle multiple qubits simultaneously, enabling universal computation with multi-qubit gates supplemented by single-qubit rotations. Using multiple tones to drive each ion individually induces Ising-type interactions, forming a multi-qubit gate, where the coupling matrix of all ion pairs is fully controllable. This reduces the total gate count while maintaining high fidelity, as opposed to traditional methods that rely on a single type of two-qubit gate, such as the well-known Mølmer-Sørensen gate. However, scaling to large ion chains, individual addressing can be technically challenging in terms of optical delivery and signal generation. We explore global and semi-global drives combined with single-qubit flips and show that these can reproduce the full set of multi-qubit gates. Although optimizing the combination of single-qubit flips is a computationally hard problem, we propose an efficient scheme to implement any desired couplings in large ion chains, yielding a concatenation scheme that uses at most $N/2$ multi-qubit gates, with $N$ being the number of ions. In addition, we show that by using $B<N$ independent semi-global fields, each driving a set of $N/B$ ions, the number of maximal multi-qubit gates is reduced to approximately $\frac{N^2}{B^2 (N-1)}$. We show how to design the driving fields that support these schemes and investigate their properties. Our results pave the way for efficient implementations of quantum algorithms in large-scale trapped-ion quantum systems.

Optical tweezer-controlled entanglement gates with trapped ion qubits

David Schwerdt [1,2], Lee Peleg [1,2], Gal Dekel [1], Lekshmi Rajagopal [1], Oz Matoki [1], Avram Gross [2], Yotam Shapira [1,2], Nitzan Akerman [1], Roee Ozeri [1,2]

Abstract

We propose an entanglement protocol where ions illuminated by optical tweezers serve as control qubits. We experimentally demonstrate this proposal with a controlled M$ø$lmer-S$ø$rensen operation on a three-ion chain, analogous to the canonical Toffoli gate. Our demonstration features cases in which the control qubit was in one of its logical basis states, and not in their superposition, due to dephasing by tweezer beam intensity fluctuations. Finally, we discuss how our protocol generalizes to a broad class of unitary operations and larger qubit systems, enabling a single-pulse implementation of $n$-controlled unitaries.

Efficient compilation of quantum circuits using multi-qubit gates

Jonathan Nemirovsky [1], Maya Chuchem [1], Yotam Shapira [1]

Abstract

As quantum processors grow in scale and reliability, the need for efficient quantum gate decomposition of circuits to a set of specific available gates, becomes ever more critical. The decomposition of a particular algorithm into a sequence of these available gates is not unique. Thus, the fidelity of an algorithm's implementation can be increased by choosing an optimized decomposition. This is true both for noisy intermediate-scale quantum platforms as well as for implementation of quantum error correction schemes. Here we present a compilation scheme which implements a general-circuit decomposition to a sequence of Ising-type, long-range, multi-qubit entangling gates, that are separated by layers of single qubit rotations. We use trapped ions as an example in which multi-qubit gates naturally arise, yet any system that has connectivity beyond nearest-neighbors may gain from our approach. We evaluate our methods using the quantum volume test over $N$ qubits. In this context, our method replaces $3N^2/2$ two-qubit gates with $2N+1$ multi-qubit gates. Furthermore, our method minimizes the magnitude of the entanglement phases, which typically enables an improved implementation fidelity, by using weaker driving fields or faster realizations. We numerically test our compilation and show that, compared to conventional realizations with sequential two-qubit gates, our compilations improves the logarithm of quantum volume by $20\%$ to $25\%$.

The inverse Mpemba effect demonstrated on a single trapped ion qubit

Shahaf Aharony Shapira, Yotam Shapira, Jovan Markov, Gianluca Teza [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Oren Raz [1], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

The Mpemba effect is a counter-intuitive phenomena in which a hot system reaches a cold temperature faster than a colder system, under otherwise identical conditions. Here we propose a quantum analog of the Mpemba effect, on the simplest quantum system, a qubit. Specifically, we show it exhibits an inverse effect, in which a cold qubit reaches a hot temperature faster than a hot qubit. Furthermore, in our system a cold qubit can heat up exponentially faster, manifesting the strong version of the effect. This occurs only for sufficiently coherent systems, making this effect quantum mechanical, i.e. due to interference effects. We experimentally demonstrate our findings on a single $^{88}\text{Sr}^+$ trapped ion qubit. The existence of this anomalous relaxation effect in simple quantum systems reveals its fundamentality, and may have a role in designing and operating quantum information processing devices.

Scalable architecture for trapped-ion quantum computing using RF traps and dynamic optical potentials

David Schwerdt [1], Lee Peleg [1], Yotam Shapira [1,2], Nadav Priel [2], Yanay Florshaim [2], Avram Gross [2], Ayelet Zalic [2], Gadi Afek [2], Nitzan Akerman [1], Ady Stern [3], Amit Ben Kish [2], Roee Ozeri [1,2]

Abstract

Qubits based on ions trapped in linear radio-frequency traps form a successful platform for quantum computing, due to their high fidelity of operations, all-to-all connectivity and degree of local control. In principle there is no fundamental limit to the number of ion-based qubits that can be confined in a single 1D register. However, in practice there are two main issues associated with long trapped-ion crystals, that stem from the 'softening' of their modes of motion, upon scaling up: high heating rates of the ions' motion, and a dense motional spectrum; both impede the performance of high-fidelity qubit operations. Here we propose a holistic, scalable architecture for quantum computing with large ion-crystals that overcomes these issues. Our method relies on dynamically-operated optical potentials, that instantaneously segment the ion-crystal into cells of a manageable size. We show that these cells behave as nearly independent quantum registers, allowing for parallel entangling gates on all cells. The ability to reconfigure the optical potentials guarantees connectivity across the full ion-crystal, and also enables efficient mid-circuit measurements. We study the implementation of large-scale parallel multi-qubit entangling gates that operate simultaneously on all cells, and present a protocol to compensate for crosstalk errors, enabling full-scale usage of an extensively large register. We illustrate that this architecture is advantageous both for fault-tolerant digital quantum computation and for analog quantum simulations.

Programmable quantum simulations on a trapped-ions quantum simulator with a global drive

Yotam Shapira [1], Jovan Markov [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Ady Stern [2], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

Simulation of quantum systems is notoriously challenging for classical computers, while quantum hardware is naturally well-suited for this task. However, the imperfections of contemporary quantum systems poses a considerable challenge in carrying out accurate simulations over long evolution times. Here we experimentally demonstrate a method for quantum simulations on a small-scale trapped ions-based quantum simulator. Our method enables quantum simulations of programmable spin-Hamiltonians, using only simple global fields, driving all qubits homogeneously and simultaneously. We measure the evolution of a quantum Ising ring and accurately reconstruct the Hamiltonian parameters, showcasing an accurate and high-fidelity simulation. Our method enables a significant reduction in the required control and depth of quantum simulations, thus generating longer evolution times with higher accuracy.

Fast design and scaling of multi-qubit gates in large-scale trapped-ion quantum computers

Lee Peleg [1,3], David Schwerdt [1], Jonathan Nemirovsky [1,3], Yotam Shapira [1,3], Nitzan Akerman [1], Ady Stern [2], Amit Ben Kish [3], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

Quantum computers based on crystals of trapped ions are a prominent technology for quantum computation. A unique feature of trapped ions is their long-range Coulomb interactions, which can be exploited to realize large-scale multiqubit entanglement gates. However, scaling up the number of qubits, $N$, in these systems, while retaining high-fidelity and high-speed operations, is challenging. Specifically, designing multiqubit entanglement gates in long ion crystals of hundreds of ions involves an NP-hard optimization problem, rendering scale-up not only a technological challenge, but also a conceptual challenge. Here we introduce a method that mitigates this challenge, effectively allowing for a polynomial-time design of fast, robust, and programmable entanglement gates, acting on the entire ion-crystal. We show that while the number of simultaneous entanglement operations scales as $N^2$, the gate duration scales as $N$, leading to a scaling advantage. We use our methods to investigate the drive-power requirements and susceptibility to noise and errors of these multiqubit gates. Our method delineates a path towards scaling up quantum computers based on ion-crystals with hundreds of qubits.

Robust two-qubit trapped ions gates using spin-dependent squeezing

Yotam Shapira [1], Sapir Cohen [2], Nitzan Akerman [1], Ady Stern [2], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

Entangling gates are an essential component of quantum computers. However, generating high-fidelity gates, in a scalable manner, remains a major challenge in all quantum information processing platforms. Accordingly, improving the fidelity and robustness of these gates has been a research focus in recent years. In trapped ions quantum computers, entangling gates are performed by driving the normal modes of motion of the ion chain, generating a spin-dependent force. Even though there has been significant progress in increasing the robustness and modularity of these gates, they are still sensitive to noise in the intensity of the driving field. Here we supplement the conventional spin-dependent displacement with spin-dependent squeezing, which enables a gate that is robust to deviations in the amplitude of the driving field. We solve the general Hamiltonian and engineer its spectrum analytically. We also endow our gate with other, more conventional, robustness properties, making it resilient to many practical sources of noise and inaccuracies.

Quantum simulations of interacting systems with broken time-reversal symmetry

Yotam Shapira [1], Tom Manovitz [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Ady Stern [2], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

Many-body systems of quantum interacting particles in which time-reversal symmetry is broken give rise to a variety of rich collective behaviors, and are therefore a major target of research in modern physics. Quantum simulators can potentially be used to explore and understand such systems, which are often beyond the computational reach of classical simulation. Of these, platforms with universal quantum control can experimentally access a wide range of physical properties. However, simultaneously achieving strong programmable interactions, strong time-reversal symmetry breaking, and high fidelity quantum control in a scalable manner is challenging. Here we realized quantum simulations of interacting, time-reversal broken quantum systems in a universal trapped-ion quantum processor. Using a scalable scheme that was recently proposed we implemented time-reversal breaking synthetic gauge fields, shown for the first time in a trapped ion chain, along with unique coupling geometries, potentially extendable to simulation of multi dimensional systems. Our high fidelity single-site resolution in control and measurement, along with highly programmable interactions, allow us to perform full state tomography of a ground state showcasing persistent current, and to observe dynamics of a time-reversal broken system with nontrivial interactions. Our results open a path towards simulation of time-reversal broken many-body systems with a wide range of features and coupling geometries.

A trapped ion quantum computer with robust entangling gates and quantum coherent feedback

Tom Manovitz [1], Yotam Shapira [1], Lior Gazit [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

Quantum computers are expected to achieve a significant speed-up over classical computers in solving a range of computational problems. Chains of ions held in a linear Paul trap are a promising platform for constructing such quantum computers, due to their long coherence times and high quality of control. Here we report on the construction of a small, five-qubit, universal quantum computer using $^{88}\text{Sr}^{+}$ ions in an RF trap. All basic operations, including initialization, quantum logic operations, and readout, are performed with high fidelity. Selective two-qubit and single-qubit gates, implemented using a narrow linewidth laser, comprise a universal gate set, allowing realization of any unitary on the quantum register. We review the main experimental tools, and describe in detail unique aspects of the computer: the use of robust entangling gates and the development of a quantum coherent feedback system through EMCCD camera acquisition. The latter is necessary for carrying out quantum error correction protocols in future experiments.

Comparing Two-Qubit and Multi-Qubit Gates within the Toric Code

David Schwerdt [1], Yotam Shapira [1], Tom Manovitz [1], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

In some quantum computing (QC) architectures, entanglement of an arbitrary number of qubits can be generated in a single operation. This property has many potential applications, and may specifically be useful for quantum error correction (QEC). Stabilizer measurements can then be implemented using a single multi-qubit gate instead of several two-qubit gates, thus reducing circuit depth. In this study, the toric code is used as a benchmark to compare the performance of two-qubit and five-qubit gates within parity-check circuits. We consider trapped ion qubits that are controlled via Raman transitions, where the primary source of error is assumed to be spontaneous photon scattering. We show that a five-qubit Mølmer-Sørensen gate offers an approximately $40\%$ improvement over two-qubit gates in terms of the fault tolerance threshold. This result indicates an advantage of using multi-qubit gates in the context of QEC.

Quantum simulations with complex geometries and synthetic gauge fields in a trapped ion chain

Tom Manovitz [1], Yotam Shapira [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Ady Stern [2], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

In recent years, arrays of atomic ions in a linear RF trap have proven to be a particularly successful platform for quantum simulation. However, a wide range of quantum models and phenomena have, so far, remained beyond the reach of such simulators. In this work we introduce a technique that can substantially extend this reach using an external field gradient along the ion chain and a global, uniform driving field. The technique can be used to generate both static and time-varying synthetic gauge fields in a linear chain of trapped ions, and enables continuous simulation of a variety of coupling geometries and topologies, including periodic boundary conditions and high dimensional Hamiltonians. We describe the technique, derive the corresponding effective Hamiltonian, propose a number of variations, and discuss the possibility of scaling to quantum-advantage sized simulators. Additionally, we suggest several possible implementations and briefly examine two: the Aharonov-Bohm ring and the frustrated triangular ladder.

Direct reconstruction of the quantum master equation dynamics of a trapped ion qubit

Eitan Ben Av [1], Yotam Shapira [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

The physics of Markovian open quantum systems can be described by quantum master equations. These are dynamical equations, that incorporate the Hamiltonian and jump operators, and generate the system's time evolution. Reconstructing the system's Hamiltonian and and its coupling to the environment from measurements is important both for fundamental research as well as for performance-evaluation of quantum machines. In this paper we introduce a method that reconstructs the dynamical equation of open quantum systems, directly from a set of expectation values of selected observables. We benchmark our technique both by a simulation and experimentally, by measuring the dynamics of a trapped $^{88}\text{Sr}^+$ ion under spontaneous photon scattering.

Theory of robust multi-qubit non-adiabatic gates for trapped-ions

Yotam Shapira [1], Ravid Shaniv [1], Tom Manovitz [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Lee Peleg [1], Lior Gazit [1], Roee Ozeri [1], Ady Stern [2]

Abstract

The prevalent approach to executing quantum algorithms on quantum computers is to break-down the algorithms to a concatenation of universal gates, typically single and two-qubit gates. However such a decomposition results in long gate sequences which are exponential in the qubit register size. Furthermore, gate fidelities tend to decrease when acting in larger qubit registers. Thus high-fidelity implementations in large qubit registers is still a prominent challenge. Here we propose and investigate multi-qubit entangling gates for trapped-ions. Our gates couple many qubits at once, allowing to decrease the total number of gates used while retaining a high gate fidelity. Our method employs all of the normal-modes of motion of the ion chain, which allows to operate outside of the adiabatic regime and at rates comparable to the secular ion-trapping frequency. Furthermore we extend our method for generating Hamiltonians which are suitable for quantum analog simulations, such as a nearest-neighbour spin Hamiltonian or the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger Hamiltonian.

Precision measurement of atomic isotope shifts using a two-isotope entangled state

Tom Manovitz, Ravid Shaniv, Yotam Shapira, Roee Ozeri [1], Nitzan Akerman [1]

Abstract

Atomic isotope shifts (ISs) are the isotope-dependent energy differences in the atomic electron energy levels. These shifts serve an important role in atomic and nuclear physics, and particularly in the latter as signatures of nuclear structure. Recently ISs have been suggested as unique probes of beyond Standard Model (SM) physics, under the condition that they be determined significantly more precisely than current state of the art. In this work we present a simple and robust method for measuring ISs with ions in a Paul trap, by taking advantage of Hilbert subspaces that are insensitive to common-mode noise yet sensitive to the IS. Using this method we evaluate the IS of the $5S_{1/2}\leftrightarrow4D_{5/2}$ transition in $^{86}\text{Sr}^+$ and $^{88}\text{Sr}^+$ with a $1.6\times10^{-11}$ relative uncertainty to be 570,264,063.435(9) Hz. Furthermore, we detect a relative difference of $3.46(23)\times10^{-8}$ between the orbital g-factors of the electrons in the $4D_{5/2}$ level of the two isotopes. Our method is relatively easy to implement and is indifferent to element or isotope, paving the way for future tabletop searches for new physics and posing interesting prospects for testing quantum many-body calculations and for the study of nuclear structure.

Quadrupole shift cancellation using dynamic decoupling

Ravid Shaniv [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Tom Manovitz [1], Yotam Shapira [1], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

We present a method that uses radio-frequency pulses to cancel the quadrupole shift in optical clock transitions. Quadrupole shifts are an inherent inhomogeneous broadening mechanism in trapped ion crystals, limiting current optical ion clocks to work with a single probe ion. Cancelling this shift at each interrogation cycle of the ion frequency allows the use of $N>1$ ions in clocks, thus reducing the uncertainty in the clock frequency by $\sqrt{N}$ according to the standard quantum limit. Our sequence relies on the tensorial nature of the quadrupole shift, and thus also cancels other tensorial shifts, such as the tensor ac stark shift. We experimentally demonstrate our sequence on three and seven $^{88}\mathrm{Sr}^{+}$ ions trapped in a linear Paul trap, using correlation spectroscopy. We show a reduction of the quadrupole shift difference between ions to $\approx20$ mHz's level where other shifts, such as the relativistic 2$^{\mathrm{nd}}$ order Doppler shift, are expected to limit our spectral resolution. In addition, we show that using radio-frequency dynamic decoupling we can also cancel the effect of 1$^{\mathrm{st}}$ order Zeeman shifts.

Robust entanglement gates for trapped-ion qubits

Yotam Shapira [1], Ravid Shaniv [1], Tom Manovitz [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

High-fidelity two-qubit entangling gates play an important role in many quantum information processing tasks and are a necessary building block for constructing a universal quantum computer. Such high-fidelity gates have been demonstrated on trapped-ion qubits, however, control errors and noise in gate parameters may still lead to reduced fidelity. Here we propose and demonstrate a general family of two-qubit entangling gates which are robust to different sources of noise and control errors. These gates generalize the celebrated Mølmer-Sørensen gate by using multi-tone drives. We experimentally implemented several of the proposed gates on $^{88}\text{Sr}^{+}$ ions trapped in a linear Paul trap, and verified their resilience.

Fast dynamical decoupling of the Molmer-Sorensen entangling gate

Tom Manovitz [1], Amit Rotem [2], Ravid Shaniv [1], Itsik Cohen [2], Yotam Shapira [1], Nitzan Akerman [1], Alex Retzker [2], Roee Ozeri [1]

Abstract

Engineering entanglement between quantum systems often involves coupling through a bosonic mediator, which should be disentangled from the systems at the operation's end. The quality of such an operation is generally limited by environmental and control noise. One of the prime techniques for suppressing noise is by dynamical decoupling, where one actively applies pulses at a rate that is faster than the typical time scale of the noise. However, for boson-mediated gates, current dynamical decoupling schemes require executing the pulses only when the boson and the quantum systems are disentangled. This restriction implies an increase of the gate time by a factor of $\sqrt{N}$, with $N$ being the number of pulses applied. Here we propose and realize a method that enables dynamical decoupling in a boson mediated system where the pulses can be applied while spin-boson entanglement persists, resulting in an increase in time that is at most a factor of $\fracπ{2}$, independently of the number of pulses applied. We experimentally demonstrate the robustness of our fast dynamically decoupled entangling gate to $σ_z$ noise with ions in a Paul trap.