F. Scott Porter

Comprehensive Laboratory Benchmark of K-shell Dielectronic Satellites of Fe XXV-XXI Ions

Chintan Shah [1,2,3], Pedro Amaro [4], Filipe Grilo [4], Ming Feng Gu [5], Liyi Gu [6,7,4], José Paulo Santos, F. Scott Porter [1], Thomas Pfeifer [2], Maurice A. Leutenegger [1,2], José R. Crespo López-Urrutia

Abstract

We report on comprehensive laboratory studies of the K-shell dielectronic recombination (DR) resonances of Fe XXV - XXI ions that prominently contribute to the hard X-ray spectrum of hot astrophysical plasmas. By scanning a monoenergetic electron beam to resonantly excite trapped Fe ions in an electron beam ion trap, and achieving a high electron-ion collision energy resolution of ~7 eV, we resolve their respective KL$n$ satellites up to n'=11. By normalization to known radiative recombination cross sections we also determine their excitation cross sections and that of the continuum with uncertainties below 15%, and verify our results with an independent normalization based on previous measurements. Our experimental data excellently confirm the accuracy and suitability of distorted-wave calculations obtained with the Flexible Atomic Code (FAC) for modeling astrophysical and fusion plasmas.

High-Precision Transition Energy Measurements of Neon-like Fe XVII Ions

Chintan Shah [1,2,3], Moto Togawa [2,4,5], Marc Botz [2,5], Jonas Danisch [2], Joschka J. Goes [2], Sonja Bernitt [6,7,8,2], Marleen Maxton [2,9,10], Kai Köbnick, Jen Buck, Jörn Seltmann, Moritz Hoesch [10], Ming Feng Gu [11], F. Scott Porter [1], Thomas Pfeifer [2], Maurice A. Leutenegger [1], Charles Cheung [12], Marianna S. Safronova [12,2], José R. Crespo López-Urrutia

Abstract

We improve by a factor of 4-20 the energy accuracy of the strongest soft X-ray transitions of Fe XVII ions by resonantly exciting them in an electron beam ion trap with a monochromatic beam at the P04 beamline of the PETRA III synchrotron facility. By simultaneously tracking instantaneous photon-energy fluctuations with a high-resolution photoelectron spectrometer, we minimize systematic uncertainties down to 10-15 meV, or velocity equivalent $\pm\sim$5 km s$^{-1}$ in their rest energies, substantially improving our knowledge of this key astrophysical ion. Our large-scale configuration-interaction computations include more than four million relativistic configurations and agree with the experiment at a level without precedent for a 10-electron system. Thereby, theoretical uncertainties for interelectronic correlations become far smaller than those of quantum electrodynamics (QED) corrections. The present QED benchmark strengthens our trust in future calculations of many other complex atomic ions of interest to astrophysics, plasma physics, and for the development of optical clocks with highly charged ions.

High-resolution Laboratory Measurements of K-shell X-ray Line Polarization and Excitation Cross Sections in Heliumlike S XV Ions

Chintan Shah [1,2,3], Natalie Hell [2], Antonia Hubbard [2], Ming Feng Gu [4], Michael J. MacDonald [2], Megan E. Eckart [2], Richard L. Kelley [5], Caroline A. Kilbourne [5], Maurice A. Leutenegger [5], F. Scott Porter [5], Gregory V. Brown [2]

Abstract

We report measurements of electron-impact excitation cross sections for the strong K-shell n=2-1 transitions in S XV using the LLNL EBIT-I electron beam ion trap, two crystal spectrometers, and the EBIT Calorimeter Spectrometer. The cross sections are determined by direct normalization to the well known cross sections of radiative electron capture, measured simultaneously. Using contemporaneous polarization measurements with the two crystal spectrometers, whose dispersion planes are oriented parallel and perpendicular to the electron beam direction, the polarization of the direct excitation line emission is determined, and in turn the isotropic total cross sections are extracted. We further experimentally investigate various line-formation mechanisms, finding that radiative cascades and collisional inner-shell ionization dominate the degree of linear polarization and total line-emission cross sections of the forbidden line $z$.

X-ray spectra of the Fe-L complex II: atomic data constraints from EBIT experiment and X-ray grating observations of Capella

Liyi Gu [1,2], Chintan Shah [3,4], Junjie Mao [5,2,6], A. J. J. Raassen, Jelle de Plaa [2], Ciro Pinto [7], Hiroki Akamatsu [2], Norbert Werner [8,9,10], Aurora Simionescu [2,11,12,13], François Mernier, Makoto Sawada [1], Pranav Mohanty [11], Pedro Amaro [14], Ming Feng Gu [15], F. Scott Porter [3,4], José R. Crespo López-Urrutia, Jelle S. Kaastra [2,11]

Abstract

The Hitomi results for the Perseus cluster have shown that accurate atomic models are essential to the success of X-ray spectroscopic missions, and just as important as knowledge on instrumental calibration and astrophysical modeling. Preparing the models requires a multifaceted approach, including theoretical calculations, laboratory measurements, and calibration using real observations. In a previous paper, we presented a calculation of the electron impact cross sections on the transitions forming the Fe-L complex. In the present work, we systematically test the calculation against cross sections of ions measured in an electron beam ion trap experiment. A two-dimensional analysis in the electron beam energies and X-ray photon energies is utilized to disentangle radiative channels following dielectronic recombination, direct electron-impact excitation, and resonant excitation processes in the experimental data. The data calibrated through laboratory measurements are further fed into global modeling of the Chandra grating spectrum of Capella. We investigate and compare the fit quality, as well as sensitivity of the derived physical parameters to the underlying atomic data and the astrophysical plasma modeling. We further list the potential areas of disagreement between the observation and the present calculations, which in turn calls for renewed efforts in theoretical calculations and targeted laboratory measurements.

Laboratory Measurements of X-Ray Emission from Highly Charged Argon Ions

Esra Bulbul [1,2], Adam Foster [2], Gregory V. Brown [3], Mark W. Bautz [1], Peter Beiersdorfer [3], Natalie Hell [3], Caroline Kilbourne [4], Ralph Kraft [2], Richard Kelley [4], Maurice A. Leutenegger [4,5], Eric D. Miller [1], F. Scott Porter [4], Randall K. Smith [2]

Abstract

Uncertainties in atomic models will introduce noticeable additional systematics in calculating the flux of weak dielectronic recombination (DR) satellite lines, affecting the detection and flux measurements of other weak spectral lines. One important example is the Ar XVII He-beta DR, which is expected to be present in emission from the hot intracluster medium (ICM) of galaxy clusters and could impact measurements of the flux of the 3.5 keV line that has been suggested as a secondary emission from a dark matter interaction. We perform a set of experiments using the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory's electron beam ion trap (EBIT-I) and the X-Ray Spectrometer quantum calorimeter (XRS/EBIT), to test the Ar XVII He-beta DR origin of the 3.5 keV line. We measured the X-ray emission following resonant DR onto helium-like and lithium-like Argon using EBIT-I's Maxwellian simulator mode at a simulated electron temperature of Te=1.74 keV. The measured flux of the Ar XVII He-beta DR lined is too weak to account for the flux in the 3.5 keV line assuming reasonable plasma parameters. We, therefore, rule out Ar XVII He-beta DR as a significant contributor to the 3.5 keV line. A comprehensive comparison between the atomic theory and the EBIT experiment results is also provided.