Marko Cetina

Hybrid digital-analog protocols for simulating quantum multi-body interactions

Or Katz [1], Alexander Schuckert [2,3], Tianyi Wang [4,5], Eleanor Crane [6], Alexey V. Gorshkov [2,3], Marko Cetina [4,5,7]

Abstract

While quantum simulators promise to explore quantum many-body physics beyond classical computation, their capabilities are limited by the available native interactions in the hardware. On many platforms, accessible Hamiltonians are largely restricted to one- and two-body interactions, limiting access to multi-body Hamiltonians and to systems governed by simultaneous, non-commuting interaction terms that are central to condensed matter, quantum chemistry, and high-energy physics. We introduce and experimentally demonstrate a hybrid digital-analog protocol that overcomes these limitations by embedding analog evolution between shallow entangling-gate layers. This method produces effective Hamiltonians with simultaneous non-commuting three- and four-body interactions that are generated non-perturbatively and without Trotter error -- capabilities not practically attainable on near-term hardware using purely digital or purely analog schemes. We implement our scheme on a trapped-ion quantum processor and use it to realize a topological spin chain exhibiting prethermal strong zero modes persisting at high temperature, as well as models featuring three- and four-body interactions. Our hardware-agnostic and scalable method opens new routes to realizing complex many-body physics across quantum platforms.

Quantum Machine Learning via Contrastive Training

Liudmila A. Zhukas [1,2,3], Vivian Ni Zhang [1,2,3], Qiang Miao [1], Qingfeng Wang [4], Marko Cetina [1,2,3], Jungsang Kim [1,2,3], Lawrence Carin [3], Christopher Monroe [1,2,3]

Abstract

Quantum machine learning (QML) has attracted growing interest with the rapid parallel advances in large-scale classical machine learning and quantum technologies. Similar to classical machine learning, QML models also face challenges arising from the scarcity of labeled data, particularly as their scale and complexity increase. Here, we introduce self-supervised pretraining of quantum representations that reduces reliance on labeled data by learning invariances from unlabeled examples. We implement this paradigm on a programmable trapped-ion quantum computer, encoding images as quantum states. In situ contrastive pretraining on hardware yields a representation that, when fine-tuned, classifies image families with higher mean test accuracy and lower run-to-run variability than models trained from random initialization. Performance improvement is especially significant in regimes with limited labeled training data. We show that the learned invariances generalize beyond the pretraining image samples. Unlike prior work, our pipeline derives similarity from measured quantum overlaps and executes all training and classification stages on hardware. These results establish a label-efficient route to quantum representation learning, with direct relevance to quantum-native datasets and a clear path to larger classical inputs.

Probing Entanglement Scaling Across a Quantum Phase Transition on a Quantum Computer

Qiang Miao [1], Tianyi Wang [2,1], Kenneth R. Brown [1,2,3,4], Thomas Barthel [1,2,5], Marko Cetina [2,1,3]

Abstract

The investigation of strongly-correlated quantum matter is difficult due to the curse of dimensionality and intricate entanglement structures. These challenges are particularly pronounced in the vicinity of continuous quantum phase transitions, where quantum fluctuations manifest across all length scales. While quantum simulators give controlled access to a number of strongly correlated systems, the study of critical phenomena has been hampered by finite-size effects arising from diverging correlation lengths. Moreover, the experimental investigation of entanglement in many-body systems has been hindered by limitations in measurement protocols. To address these challenges, we employ the multiscale entanglement renormalization ansatz (MERA) and implement a holographic scheme for subsystem tomography on a fully-connected trapped-ion quantum computer. Our method accurately represents infinite systems and long-range correlations with few qubits, facilitating the efficient extraction of observables and entanglement properties, even at criticality. We observe a quantum phase transition with spontaneous symmetry breaking and reveal the evolution of entanglement properties across the critical point. For the first time, we demonstrate log-law scaling of subsystem entanglement entropies at criticality on a digital quantum computer. This achievement highlights the potential of MERA for the investigation of strongly-correlated many-body systems on quantum computers.

Quantum Computing Universal Thermalization Dynamics in a (2+1)D Lattice Gauge Theory

Niklas Mueller [1,2,3], Tianyi Wang [4,5,6], Or Katz [5,7,8], Zohreh Davoudi [9,10,6,11], Marko Cetina [4,5,7,6]

Abstract

Simulating non-equilibrium phenomena in strongly-interacting quantum many-body systems, including thermalization, is a promising application of near-term and future quantum computation. By performing experiments on a digital quantum computer consisting of fully-connected optically-controlled trapped ions, we study the role of entanglement in the thermalization dynamics of a $Z_2$ lattice gauge theory in 2+1 spacetime dimensions. Using randomized-measurement protocols, we efficiently learn a classical approximation of non-equilibrium states that yields the gap-ratio distribution and the spectral form factor of the entanglement Hamiltonian. These observables exhibit universal early-time signals for quantum chaos, a prerequisite for thermalization. Our work, therefore, establishes quantum computers as robust tools for studying universal features of thermalization in complex many-body systems, including in gauge theories.

Comparing Shor and Steane Error Correction Using the Bacon-Shor Code

Shilin Huang [1,2], Kenneth R. Brown [1,2,3,4], Marko Cetina [1,3]

Abstract

Quantum states can quickly decohere through interaction with the environment. Quantum error correction is a method for preserving coherence through active feedback. Quantum error correction encodes the quantum information into a logical state with a high-degree of symmetry. Perturbations are first detected by measuring the symmetries of the quantum state and then corrected by applying a set of gates based on the measurements. In order to measure the symmetries without perturbing the data, ancillary quantum states are required. Shor error correction uses a separate quantum state for the measurement of each symmetry. Steane error correction maps the perturbations onto a logical ancilla qubit, which is then measured to check several symmetries simultaneously. Here we experimentally compare Shor and Steane correction of bit flip errors using the Bacon-Shor code implemented in a chain of 23 trapped atomic ions. We find that the Steane error correction provides better logical error rates after a single-round of error correction and less disturbance to the data qubits without error correction.

Continuous Symmetry Breaking in a Trapped-Ion Spin Chain

Lei Feng [1], Or Katz [1], Casey Haack [2], Mohammad Maghrebi [3], Alexey V. Gorshkov [4], Zhexuan Gong [2], Marko Cetina [1], Christopher Monroe [1,5]

Abstract

One-dimensional systems exhibiting a continuous symmetry can host quantum phases of matter with true long-range order only in the presence of sufficiently long-range interactions. In most physical systems, however, the interactions are short-ranged, hindering the emergence of such phases in one dimension. Here we use a one-dimensional trapped-ion quantum simulator to prepare states with long-range spin order that extends over the system size of up to $23$ spins and is characteristic of the continuous symmetry-breaking phase of matter. Our preparation relies on simultaneous control over an array of tightly focused individual-addressing laser beams, generating long-range spin-spin interactions. We also observe a disordered phase with frustrated correlations. We further study the phases at different ranges of interaction and the out-of-equilibrium response to symmetry-breaking perturbations. This work opens an avenue to study new quantum phases and out-of-equilibrium dynamics in low-dimensional systems.

Experimental Implementation of an Efficient Test of Quantumness

Laura Lewis [1,2], Daiwei Zhu [3,4,5], Alexandru Gheorghiu [7], Crystal Noel [3,8,9], Or Katz [8,9], Bahaa Harraz [3], Qingfeng Wang [3,4,10], Andrew Risinger [3,4], Lei Feng [3,4], Debopriyo Biswas [3,4], Laird Egan [3,4], Thomas Vidick [1], Marko Cetina [3,8], Christopher Monroe [3,4,5,8,9]

Abstract

A test of quantumness is a protocol where a classical user issues challenges to a quantum device to determine if it exhibits non-classical behavior, under certain cryptographic assumptions. Recent attempts to implement such tests on current quantum computers rely on either interactive challenges with efficient verification, or non-interactive challenges with inefficient (exponential time) verification. In this paper, we execute an efficient non-interactive test of quantumness on an ion-trap quantum computer. Our results significantly exceed the bound for a classical device's success.

Demonstration of three- and four-body interactions between trapped-ion spins

Or Katz [1,2,3], Lei Feng [1,2,3], Andrew Risinger [4], Christopher Monroe [1,2,3,5], Marko Cetina [1,2,3]

Abstract

Quantum processors use the native interactions between effective spins to simulate Hamiltonians or execute quantum gates. In most processors, the native interactions are pairwise, limiting the efficiency of controlling entanglement between many qubits. Here we experimentally demonstrate a new class of native interactions between trapped-ion qubits, extending conventional pairwise interactions to higher order. We realize three- and four-body spin interactions as examples, showing that high-order spin polynomials may serve as a new toolbox for quantum information applications.

Programmable N-body interactions with trapped ions

Or Katz [1,2,3], Marko Cetina [1,3], Christopher Monroe [1,2,3,4]

Abstract

Trapped atomic ion qubits or effective spins are a powerful quantum platform for quantum computation and simulation, featuring densely connected and efficiently programmable interactions between the spins. While native interactions between trapped ion spins are typically pairwise, many quantum algorithms and quantum spin models naturally feature couplings between triplets, quartets or higher orders of spins. Here we formulate and analyze a mechanism that extends the standard Mølmer-Sørensen pairwise entangling gate and generates a controllable and programmable coupling between $N$ spins of trapped ions. We show that spin-dependent optical forces applied at twice the motional frequency generate a coordinate-transformation of the collective ion motion in phase-space, rendering displacement forces that are nonlinear in the spin operators. We formulate a simple framework that enables a systematic and faithful construction of high-order spin Hamiltonians and gates, including the effect of multiple modes of motion, and characterize the performance of such operations under realistic conditions.

$N$-body interactions between trapped ion qubits via spin-dependent squeezing

Or Katz [1,2,3], Marko Cetina [1,3], Christopher Monroe [1,2,3,4]

Abstract

We describe a simple protocol for the single-step generation of $N$-body entangling interactions between trapped atomic ion qubits. We show that qubit state-dependent squeezing operations and displacement forces on the collective atomic motion can generate full $N$-body interactions. Similar to the Mølmer-Sørensen two-body Ising interaction at the core of most trapped ion quantum computers and simulators, the proposed operation is relatively insensitive to the state of motion. We show how this $N$-body gate operation allows the single-step implementation of a family of $N$-bit gate operations such as the powerful $N$-Toffoli gate, which flips a single qubit if and only if all other $N$-$1$ qubits are in a particular state.

Interactive Protocols for Classically-Verifiable Quantum Advantage

Daiwei Zhu [1,2,9], Gregory D. Kahanamoku-Meyer [3,4], Laura Lewis [5,6], Crystal Noel [1,7,8], Or Katz [7,8], Bahaa Harraz [1], Qingfeng Wang [1,2,11], Andrew Risinger [1,2], Lei Feng [1,2], Debopriyo Biswas [1,2], Laird Egan [1,2], Alexandru Gheorghiu [5,10], Yunseong Nam [9], Thomas Vidick [5], Umesh Vazirani [3,4], Norman Y. Yao [3,4], Marko Cetina [1,7], Christopher Monroe [1,2,7,8,9]

Abstract

Achieving quantum computational advantage requires solving a classically intractable problem on a quantum device. Natural proposals rely upon the intrinsic hardness of classically simulating quantum mechanics; however, verifying the output is itself classically intractable. On the other hand, certain quantum algorithms (e.g. prime factorization via Shor's algorithm) are efficiently verifiable, but require more resources than what is available on near-term devices. One way to bridge the gap between verifiability and implementation is to use "interactions" between a prover and a verifier. By leveraging cryptographic functions, such protocols enable the classical verifier to enforce consistency in a quantum prover's responses across multiple rounds of interaction. In this work, we demonstrate the first implementation of an interactive quantum advantage protocol, using an ion trap quantum computer. We execute two complementary protocols -- one based upon the learning with errors problem and another where the cryptographic construction implements a computational Bell test. To perform multiple rounds of interaction, we implement mid-circuit measurements on a subset of trapped ion qubits, with subsequent coherent evolution. For both protocols, the performance exceeds the asymptotic bound for classical behavior; maintaining this fidelity at scale would conclusively demonstrate verifiable quantum advantage.

Digital quantum simulation of NMR experiments

Kushal Seetharam [1,2], Debopriyo Biswas [3,4], Crystal Noel [3,4], Andrew Risinger [4], Daiwei Zhu [4], Or Katz [3], Sambuddha Chattopadhyay [2], Marko Cetina [4,5], Christopher Monroe [3,4,6], Eugene Demler [7], Dries Sels [8,9]

Abstract

Simulations of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments can be an important tool for extracting information about molecular structure and optimizing experimental protocols but are often intractable on classical computers for large molecules such as proteins and for protocols such as zero-field NMR. We demonstrate the first quantum simulation of an NMR spectrum, computing the zero-field spectrum of the methyl group of acetonitrile using four qubits of a trapped-ion quantum computer. We reduce the sampling cost of the quantum simulation by an order of magnitude using compressed sensing techniques. We show how the intrinsic decoherence of NMR systems may enable the zero-field simulation of classically hard molecules on relatively near-term quantum hardware and discuss how the experimentally demonstrated quantum algorithm can be used to efficiently simulate scientifically and technologically relevant solid-state NMR experiments on more mature devices. Our work opens a practical application for quantum computation.

Any-to-any connected cavity-mediated architecture for quantum computing with trapped ions or Rydberg arrays

Joshua Ramette [1], Josiah Sinclair [1], Zachary Vendeiro [1], Alyssa Rudelis [1], Marko Cetina [2,1], Vladan Vuletić

Abstract

We propose a hardware architecture and protocol for connecting many local quantum processors contained within an optical cavity. The scheme is compatible with trapped ions or Rydberg arrays, and realizes teleported gates between any two qubits by distributing entanglement via single-photon transfers through a cavity. Heralding enables high-fidelity entanglement even for a cavity of moderate quality. For processors composed of trapped ions in a linear chain, a single cavity with realistic parameters successfully transfers photons every few $μ$s, enabling the any-to-any entanglement of 20 ion chains containing a total of 500 qubits in 200 $μ$s, with both fidelities and rates limited only by local operations and ion readout. For processors composed of Rydberg atoms, our method fully connects a large array of thousands of neutral atoms. The connectivity afforded by our architecture is extendable to tens of thousands of qubits using multiple overlapping cavities, expanding capabilities for NISQ era algorithms and Hamiltonian simulations, as well as enabling more robust high-dimensional error correcting schemes.

Observation of measurement-induced quantum phases in a trapped-ion quantum computer

Crystal Noel [1,3,4], Pradeep Niroula [1,2], Daiwei Zhu [1], Andrew Risinger [1], Laird Egan [1], Debopriyo Biswas [1], Marko Cetina [1,3], Alexey V. Gorshkov [1,2], Michael J. Gullans [2], David A. Huse [5], Christopher Monroe [1,2,3,4,6]

Abstract

Many-body open quantum systems balance internal dynamics against decoherence from interactions with an environment. Here, we explore this balance via random quantum circuits implemented on a trapped ion quantum computer, where the system evolution is represented by unitary gates with interspersed projective measurements. As the measurement rate is varied, a purification phase transition is predicted to emerge at a critical point akin to a fault-tolerent threshold. We probe the "pure" phase, where the system is rapidly projected to a deterministic state conditioned on the measurement outcomes, and the "mixed" or "coding" phase, where the initial state becomes partially encoded into a quantum error correcting codespace. We find convincing evidence of the two phases and show numerically that, with modest system scaling, critical properties of the transition clearly emerge.

Optimizing Stabilizer Parities for Improved Logical Qubit Memories

Dripto M. Debroy [1], Laird Egan [2], Crystal Noel [1,2,3], Andrew Risinger [2], Daiwei Zhu [2], Debopriyo Biswas [2], Marko Cetina [1,2], Chris Monroe [1,2,3,4], Kenneth R. Brown [1,3]

Abstract

We study variants of Shor's code that are adept at handling single-axis correlated idling errors, which are commonly observed in many quantum systems. By using the repetition code structure of the Shor's code basis states, we calculate the logical channel applied to the encoded information when subjected to coherent and correlated single qubit idling errors, followed by stabilizer measurement. Changing the signs of the stabilizer generators allows us to change how the coherent errors interfere, leading to a quantum error correcting code which performs as well as a classical repetition code of equivalent distance against these errors. We demonstrate a factor of 4 improvement of the logical memory in a distance-3 logical qubit implemented on a trapped-ion quantum computer. Even-distance versions of our Shor code variants are decoherence-free subspaces and fully robust to identical and independent coherent idling noise.

Fault-Tolerant Operation of a Quantum Error-Correction Code

Laird Egan [1], Dripto M. Debroy [2], Crystal Noel [1], Andrew Risinger [1], Daiwei Zhu [1], Debopriyo Biswas [1], Michael Newman [3], Muyuan Li [5], Kenneth R. Brown [2,3,4,5], Marko Cetina [1,2], Christopher Monroe [1]

Abstract

Quantum error correction protects fragile quantum information by encoding it into a larger quantum system. These extra degrees of freedom enable the detection and correction of errors, but also increase the operational complexity of the encoded logical qubit. Fault-tolerant circuits contain the spread of errors while operating the logical qubit, and are essential for realizing error suppression in practice. While fault-tolerant design works in principle, it has not previously been demonstrated in an error-corrected physical system with native noise characteristics. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate fault-tolerant preparation, measurement, rotation, and stabilizer measurement of a Bacon-Shor logical qubit using 13 trapped ion qubits. When we compare these fault-tolerant protocols to non-fault tolerant protocols, we see significant reductions in the error rates of the logical primitives in the presence of noise. The result of fault-tolerant design is an average state preparation and measurement error of 0.6% and a Clifford gate error of 0.3% after error correction. Additionally, we prepare magic states with fidelities exceeding the distillation threshold, demonstrating all of the key single-qubit ingredients required for universal fault-tolerant operation. These results demonstrate that fault-tolerant circuits enable highly accurate logical primitives in current quantum systems. With improved two-qubit gates and the use of intermediate measurements, a stabilized logical qubit can be achieved.

Suppression of Ion Transport due to Long-Lived Sub-Wavelength Localization by an Optical Lattice

Leon Karpa [1], Alexei Bylinskii [1], Dorian Gangloff [1], Marko Cetina [1,2], Vladan Vuletić

Abstract

We report the localization of an ion by a one-dimensional optical lattice in the presence of an applied external force. The ion is confined radially by a radiofrequency trap and axially by a combined electrostatic and optical-lattice potential. The ion is cooled using a resolved Raman sideband technique to a mean vibrational number <n> = 0.6 \pm 0.1 along the optical lattice. We implement a detection method to monitor the position of the ion subject to a periodic electrical driving force with a resolution down to λ/40, and demonstrate suppression of the driven ion motion and localization to a single lattice site on time scales of up to 10 milliseconds. This opens new possibilities for studying many-body systems with long-range interactions in periodic potentials.

One-dimensional array of ion chains coupled to an optical cavity

Marko Cetina, Alexei Bylinskii, Leon Karpa, Dorian Gangloff, Kristin M. Beck, Yufei Ge, Matthias Scholz, Andrew T. Grier [1], Isaac Chuang [1], Vladan Vuletic

Abstract

We present a novel hybrid system where an optical cavity is integrated with a microfabricated planar-electrode ion trap. The trap electrodes produce a tunable periodic potential allowing the trapping of up to 50 separate ion chains spaced by 160 $μ$m along the cavity axis. Each chain can contain up to 20 individually addressable Yb\textsuperscript{+} ions coupled to the cavity mode. We demonstrate deterministic distribution of ions between the sites of the electrostatic periodic potential and control of the ion-cavity coupling. The measured strength of this coupling should allow access to the strong collective coupling regime with $\lesssim$10 ions. The optical cavity could serve as a quantum information bus between ions or be used to generate a strong wavelength-scale periodic optical potential.

Micromotion-induced Limit to Atom-Ion Sympathetic Cooling in Paul Traps

Marko Cetina [1], Andrew T. Grier [1], Vladan Vuletić

Abstract

We present and derive analytic expressions for a fundamental limit to the sympathetic cooling of ions in radio-frequency traps using cold atoms. The limit arises from the work done by the trap electric field during a long-range ion-atom collision and applies even to cooling by a zero-temperature atomic gas in a perfectly compensated trap. We conclude that in current experimental implementations this collisional heating prevents access to the regimes of single-partial-wave atom-ion interaction or quantized ion motion. We determine conditions on the atom-ion mass ratio and on the trap parameters for reaching the s-wave collision regime and the trap ground state.

A microfabricated surface ion trap on a high-finesse optical mirror

Peter F. Herskind [1], Shannon X. Wang [1], Molu Shi [1], Yufei Ge [1], Marko Cetina [1], Isaac L. Chuang [1]

Abstract

A novel approach to optics integration in ion traps is demonstrated based on a surface electrode ion trap that is microfabricated on top of a dielectric mirror. Additional optical losses due to fabrication are found to be as low as 80 ppm for light at 422 nm. The integrated mirror is used to demonstrate light collection from, and imaging of, a single 88 Sr+ ion trapped $169\pm4 μ$m above the mirror.

Observation of Cold Collisions between Trapped Ions and Trapped Atoms

Andrew T. Grier [1], Marko Cetina [1], Fedja OruÄ\udc8dević, Vladan Vuletić

Abstract

We demonstrate a double-trap system well suited to study cold collisions between trapped ions and trapped atoms. Using Yb$^+$ ions confined in a Paul trap and Yb atoms in a magneto-optical trap, we investigate charge-exchange collisions of several isotopes for collision energies down to 400 neV (5 mK). The measured rate coefficient of $6 \times 10^{-10}$ cm$^{3}$s$^{-1}$, constant over four orders of magnitude in collision energy, is in good agreement with that derived from a semiclassical Langevin model for an atomic polarizability of 143 a.u.

Bright Source of Cold Ions for Surface-Electrode Traps

Marko Cetina [1], Andrew Grier [1], Jonathan Campbell [2], Isaac Chuang [1], Vladan Vuletic

Abstract

We produce large numbers of low-energy ions by photoionization of laser-cooled atoms inside a surface-electrode-based Paul trap. The isotope-selective trap loading rate of $4\times10^{5}$ Yb$^{+}$ ions/s exceeds that attained by photoionization (electron impact ionization) of an atomic beam by four (six) orders of magnitude. Traps as shallow as 0.13 eV are easily loaded with this technique. The ions are confined in the same spatial region as the laser-cooled atoms, which will allow the experimental investigation of interactions between cold ions and cold atoms or Bose-Einstein condensates.