Daiwei Zhu

Continuous-angle logical rotations in the Steane code

Eric Huang, Daiwei Zhu, Matteo Ippoliti, Christopher Monroe, Michael J. Gullans

Abstract

We experimentally demonstrate continuous-angle logical $Z$ rotations in the $[[7,1,3]]$ Steane code on the IonQ Forte trapped-ion processor. A round of the protocol applies a transversal physical $Z$ rotation by $θ$, followed by Steane syndrome extraction and decoding, which induces a syndrome-dependent logical $Z$ rotation. We analytically derive the effect of dephasing noise on the logical rotation angle and logical dephasing rate. Using logical Ramsey interferometry, we observe coherent syndrome-dependent logical rotations from a single round of the protocol. We find that the logical channel reconstructed from process tomography is a noisy logical $Z$ rotation well explained by a dephasing model. We further implement a two-round protocol applying physical rotations $+θ$ and $-θ$, and observe cancellation of the total logical angle with low logical dephasing for repeated trivial syndromes. This constitutes a proof-of-principle demonstration of continuously tunable non-Clifford logical gates by transversal rotations and standard error correction in a small quantum code.

Observation of gravity-like signatures in holographic codes on a quantum computer

Debopriyo Biswas, Gong Cheng, Krishnanand Karthikeyan, Diana Muñoz-Valencia, Vincent P. Su, Hrant Gharibyan, Daiwei Zhu, Grant Salton, Evgeny Epifanovsky, Martin Roetteler, Christopher Monroe, John Preskill, Norbert M. Linke, ChunJun Cao, Crystal Noel

Abstract

The unification of quantum mechanics and general relativity remains one of the major open problems of theoretical physics. The Anti-de Sitter/Conformal Field Theory (AdS/CFT) correspondence provides a valuable theoretical framework for this effort via a holographic duality between a theory of quantum gravity in asymptotically AdS spacetime and a conformal quantum field theory on the lower-dimensional boundary. Here, we implement a toy model of this duality called the HaPPY code, a quantum error-correcting code in the form of a tensor network with hyperbolic entanglement patterns, on a trapped-ion quantum computer. We present the first experimental confirmation of the Faulkner-Lewkowycz-Maldacena formula in this model - a key test of the holographic correspondence. We then enrich it with non-stabilizerness, or magic, and observe entropic precursors expected of emergent gravity. Finally, we present and measure a code construction whose entropic behavior is reminiscent of a highly quantum wormhole. Our experiments illustrate how quantum computers can serve as testbeds for modeling the emergence of spacetime.

Hybrid Quantum-Classical Optimization Workflows for the Shipment Selection Problem

Miguel Angel Lopez-Ruiz, Daiwei Zhu, Jonas Hatzenbuhler, Shudian Zhao, Claudio Girotto, Willie Aboumrad, Jonas Alm, Julia Kompalla, Mena Issler, Ananth Kaushik, Martin Roetteler

Abstract

We present a quantum optimization framework for the Shipment Selection Problem (SSP) in electric freight logistics, developed jointly by IonQ and Einride. Idle gaps arising from stochastic shipment cancellations reduce fleet utilization and revenue; filling them optimally requires solving a combinatorial assignment problem with quadratic inter-gap dependencies. We formulate the SSP as a Mixed-Integer Quadratic Program, map it to an Ising cost Hamiltonian, and solve it using Iterative-QAOA, a non-variational warm-start extension of the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) with a fixed linear-ramp parameter schedule. An end-to-end hybrid workflow integrates Einride's vehicle routing problem (VRP) solver with IonQ's quantum simulations, enabling evaluation on real, anonymized logistics data spanning up to 130 qubits. We assess solution quality through application-level performance metrics, including Shipments Delivered (SD), Schedule Compatibility Score (SCS), and Total Drive Distance (TDD). When the quantum assignment is passed to the classical solver as a warm start, the resulting hybrid workflow achieves improvements of up to 12% in SD and a reduction of up to 6% in total drive distance per shipment for specific instances, while total operational cost remains effectively unchanged. For the subset of instances within reach of current devices (20-35 qubits), the workflow is additionally executed on IonQ trapped-ion quantum hardware, where the hardware results closely reproduce the noiseless simulations. These results show that Iterative-QAOA can generate compatibility-aware assignments that become operationally valuable when embedded in a hybrid logistics optimization workflow.

Quantum Kernel Machine Learning for Autonomous Materials Science

Felix Adams [1], Daiwei Zhu [2], David W. Steuerman [2], A. Gilad Kusne [1,3], Ichiro Takeuchi [1,4]

Abstract

Autonomous materials science, where active learning is used to navigate large compositional phase space, has emerged as a powerful vehicle to rapidly explore new materials. A crucial aspect of autonomous materials science is exploring new materials using as little data as possible. Gaussian process-based active learning allows effective charting of multi-dimensional parameter space with a limited number of training data, and thus is a common algorithmic choice for autonomous materials science. An integral part of the autonomous workflow is the application of kernel functions for quantifying similarities among measured data points. A recent theoretical breakthrough has shown that quantum kernel models can achieve similar performance with less training data than classical models. This signals the possible advantage of applying quantum kernel machine learning to autonomous materials discovery. In this work, we compare quantum and classical kernels for their utility in sequential phase space navigation for autonomous materials science. Specifically, we compute a quantum kernel and several classical kernels for x-ray diffraction patterns taken from an Fe-Ga-Pd ternary composition spread library. We conduct our study on both IonQ's Aria trapped ion quantum computer hardware and the corresponding classical noisy simulator. We experimentally verify that a quantum kernel model can outperform some classical kernel models. The results highlight the potential of quantum kernel machine learning methods for accelerating materials discovery and suggest complex x-ray diffraction data is a candidate for robust quantum kernel model advantage.

Trapped-ion quantum simulation of the Fermi-Hubbard model as a lattice gauge theory using hardware-aware native gates

Dhruv Srinivasan [1,2], Alex Beyer [1], Daiwei Zhu [3], Pranav Srikanth [1,4], Spencer Churchill [3], Kushagra Mehta [2], Sashank Kaushik Sridhar [1], Kushal Chakrabarti [5], David W. Steuerman [3,6], Nikhil Chopra [1], Avik Dutt [1,7,6]

Abstract

The Fermi-Hubbard model (FHM) is a simple yet rich model of strongly interacting electrons with complex dynamics and a variety of emerging quantum phases. These properties make it a compelling target for digital quantum simulation. Trotterization-based quantum simulations have shown promise, but implementations on current hardware are limited by noise, necessitating error mitigation techniques like circuit optimization and post-selection. A mapping of the FHM to a Z2 LGT was recently proposed that restricts the dynamics to a subspace protected by additional symmetries, and its ability for post-selection error mitigation was verified through noisy classical simulations. In this work, we propose and demonstrate a suite of algorithm-hardware co-design strategies on a trapped-ion quantum computer, targeting two key aspects of NISQ-era quantum simulation: circuit compilation and error mitigation. In particular, a novel combination of iteratively preconditioned gradient descent (IPG) and subsystem von Neumann Entropy compression reduces the 2-qubit gate count of FHM quantum simulation by 35%, consequently doubling the number of simulatable Trotter steps when used in tandem with error mitigation based on conserved symmetries, debiasing and sharpening techniques. Our work demonstrates the value of algorithm-hardware co-design to operate digital quantum simulators at the threshold of maximum circuit depths allowed by current hardware, and is broadly generalizable to strongly correlated systems in quantum chemistry and materials science.

Quantum computation: Efficient network partitioning for large scale critical infrastructures

Saikat Ray Majumder, Annarita Giani, Weiwei Shen, Bogdan Neculaes, Daiwei Zhu, Sonika Johri [7]

Abstract

Quantum computers are emerging as a viable alternative to tackle certain computational problems that are challenging for classical computers. With the rapid development of quantum hardware such as those based on trapped ions, there is practical motivation for identifying risk management problems that are efficiently solvable with these systems. Here we focus on network partitioning as a means for analyzing risk in critical infrastructures and present a quantum approach for its implementation. It is based on the potential speedup quantum computers can provide in the identification of eigenvalues and eigenvectors of sparse graph Laplacians, a procedure which is constrained by time and memory on classical computers.

Experimental Implementation of an Efficient Test of Quantumness

Laura Lewis [1,2], Daiwei Zhu [3,4,5], Alexandru Gheorghiu [7], Crystal Noel [3,8,9], Or Katz [8,9], Bahaa Harraz [3], Qingfeng Wang [3,4,10], Andrew Risinger [3,4], Lei Feng [3,4], Debopriyo Biswas [3,4], Laird Egan [3,4], Thomas Vidick [1], Marko Cetina [3,8], Christopher Monroe [3,4,5,8,9]

Abstract

A test of quantumness is a protocol where a classical user issues challenges to a quantum device to determine if it exhibits non-classical behavior, under certain cryptographic assumptions. Recent attempts to implement such tests on current quantum computers rely on either interactive challenges with efficient verification, or non-interactive challenges with inefficient (exponential time) verification. In this paper, we execute an efficient non-interactive test of quantumness on an ion-trap quantum computer. Our results significantly exceed the bound for a classical device's success.

Copula-based Risk Aggregation with Trapped Ion Quantum Computers

Daiwei Zhu [1], Weiwei Shen [1], Annarita Giani [1], Saikat Ray Majumder [1], Bogdan Neculaes [1], Sonika Johri [1]

Abstract

Copulas are mathematical tools for modeling joint probability distributions. Since copulas enable one to conveniently treat the marginal distribution of each variable and the interdependencies among variables separately, in the past 60 years they have become an essential analysis tool on classical computers in various fields ranging from quantitative finance and civil engineering to signal processing and medicine. The recent finding that copulas can be expressed as maximally entangled quantum states has revealed a promising approach to practical quantum advantages: performing tasks faster, requiring less memory, or, as we show, yielding better predictions. Studying the scalability of this quantum approach as both the precision and the number of modeled variables increase is crucial for its adoption in real-world applications. In this paper, we successfully apply a Quantum Circuit Born Machine (QCBM) based approach to modeling 3- and 4-variable copulas on trapped ion quantum computers. We study the training of QCBMs with different levels of precision and circuit design on a simulator and a state-of-the-art trapped ion quantum computer. We observe decreased training efficacy due to the increased complexity in parameter optimization as the models scale up. To address this challenge, we introduce an annealing-inspired strategy that dramatically improves the training results. In our end-to-end tests, various configurations of the quantum models make a comparable or better prediction in risk aggregation tasks than the standard classical models. Our detailed study of the copula paradigm using quantum computing opens opportunities for its deployment in various industries.

Interactive Protocols for Classically-Verifiable Quantum Advantage

Daiwei Zhu [1,2,9], Gregory D. Kahanamoku-Meyer [3,4], Laura Lewis [5,6], Crystal Noel [1,7,8], Or Katz [7,8], Bahaa Harraz [1], Qingfeng Wang [1,2,11], Andrew Risinger [1,2], Lei Feng [1,2], Debopriyo Biswas [1,2], Laird Egan [1,2], Alexandru Gheorghiu [5,10], Yunseong Nam [9], Thomas Vidick [5], Umesh Vazirani [3,4], Norman Y. Yao [3,4], Marko Cetina [1,7], Christopher Monroe [1,2,7,8,9]

Abstract

Achieving quantum computational advantage requires solving a classically intractable problem on a quantum device. Natural proposals rely upon the intrinsic hardness of classically simulating quantum mechanics; however, verifying the output is itself classically intractable. On the other hand, certain quantum algorithms (e.g. prime factorization via Shor's algorithm) are efficiently verifiable, but require more resources than what is available on near-term devices. One way to bridge the gap between verifiability and implementation is to use "interactions" between a prover and a verifier. By leveraging cryptographic functions, such protocols enable the classical verifier to enforce consistency in a quantum prover's responses across multiple rounds of interaction. In this work, we demonstrate the first implementation of an interactive quantum advantage protocol, using an ion trap quantum computer. We execute two complementary protocols -- one based upon the learning with errors problem and another where the cryptographic construction implements a computational Bell test. To perform multiple rounds of interaction, we implement mid-circuit measurements on a subset of trapped ion qubits, with subsequent coherent evolution. For both protocols, the performance exceeds the asymptotic bound for classical behavior; maintaining this fidelity at scale would conclusively demonstrate verifiable quantum advantage.

Digital quantum simulation of NMR experiments

Kushal Seetharam [1,2], Debopriyo Biswas [3,4], Crystal Noel [3,4], Andrew Risinger [4], Daiwei Zhu [4], Or Katz [3], Sambuddha Chattopadhyay [2], Marko Cetina [4,5], Christopher Monroe [3,4,6], Eugene Demler [7], Dries Sels [8,9]

Abstract

Simulations of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments can be an important tool for extracting information about molecular structure and optimizing experimental protocols but are often intractable on classical computers for large molecules such as proteins and for protocols such as zero-field NMR. We demonstrate the first quantum simulation of an NMR spectrum, computing the zero-field spectrum of the methyl group of acetonitrile using four qubits of a trapped-ion quantum computer. We reduce the sampling cost of the quantum simulation by an order of magnitude using compressed sensing techniques. We show how the intrinsic decoherence of NMR systems may enable the zero-field simulation of classically hard molecules on relatively near-term quantum hardware and discuss how the experimentally demonstrated quantum algorithm can be used to efficiently simulate scientifically and technologically relevant solid-state NMR experiments on more mature devices. Our work opens a practical application for quantum computation.

Observation of measurement-induced quantum phases in a trapped-ion quantum computer

Crystal Noel [1,3,4], Pradeep Niroula [1,2], Daiwei Zhu [1], Andrew Risinger [1], Laird Egan [1], Debopriyo Biswas [1], Marko Cetina [1,3], Alexey V. Gorshkov [1,2], Michael J. Gullans [2], David A. Huse [5], Christopher Monroe [1,2,3,4,6]

Abstract

Many-body open quantum systems balance internal dynamics against decoherence from interactions with an environment. Here, we explore this balance via random quantum circuits implemented on a trapped ion quantum computer, where the system evolution is represented by unitary gates with interspersed projective measurements. As the measurement rate is varied, a purification phase transition is predicted to emerge at a critical point akin to a fault-tolerent threshold. We probe the "pure" phase, where the system is rapidly projected to a deterministic state conditioned on the measurement outcomes, and the "mixed" or "coding" phase, where the initial state becomes partially encoded into a quantum error correcting codespace. We find convincing evidence of the two phases and show numerically that, with modest system scaling, critical properties of the transition clearly emerge.

Optimizing Stabilizer Parities for Improved Logical Qubit Memories

Dripto M. Debroy [1], Laird Egan [2], Crystal Noel [1,2,3], Andrew Risinger [2], Daiwei Zhu [2], Debopriyo Biswas [2], Marko Cetina [1,2], Chris Monroe [1,2,3,4], Kenneth R. Brown [1,3]

Abstract

We study variants of Shor's code that are adept at handling single-axis correlated idling errors, which are commonly observed in many quantum systems. By using the repetition code structure of the Shor's code basis states, we calculate the logical channel applied to the encoded information when subjected to coherent and correlated single qubit idling errors, followed by stabilizer measurement. Changing the signs of the stabilizer generators allows us to change how the coherent errors interfere, leading to a quantum error correcting code which performs as well as a classical repetition code of equivalent distance against these errors. We demonstrate a factor of 4 improvement of the logical memory in a distance-3 logical qubit implemented on a trapped-ion quantum computer. Even-distance versions of our Shor code variants are decoherence-free subspaces and fully robust to identical and independent coherent idling noise.

Demonstration of Shor encoding on a trapped-ion quantum computer

Nhung H. Nguyen [1], Muyuan Li, Alaina M. Green [1], Cinthia Huerta Alderete [1], Yingyue Zhu [1], Daiwei Zhu [1], Kenneth R. Brown, Norbert M. Linke [1]

Abstract

Fault-tolerant quantum error correction (QEC) is crucial for unlocking the true power of quantum computers. QEC codes use multiple physical qubits to encode a logical qubit, which is protected against errors at the physical qubit level. Here we use a trapped ion system to experimentally prepare $m$-qubit GHZ states and sample the measurement results to construct $m\times m$ logical states of the $[[m^2,1,m]]$ Shor code, up to $m=7$. The synthetic logical fidelity shows how deeper encoding can compensate for additional gate errors in state preparation for larger logical states. However, the optimal code size depends on the physical error rate and we find that $m=5$ has the best performance in our system. We further realize the direct logical encoding of the $[[9,1,3]]$ Shor code on nine qubits in a thirteen-ion chain for comparison, with $98.8(1)\%$ and $98.5(1)\%$ fidelity for state $\left\vert\pm\right\rangle_L$, respectively.

Fault-Tolerant Operation of a Quantum Error-Correction Code

Laird Egan [1], Dripto M. Debroy [2], Crystal Noel [1], Andrew Risinger [1], Daiwei Zhu [1], Debopriyo Biswas [1], Michael Newman [3], Muyuan Li [5], Kenneth R. Brown [2,3,4,5], Marko Cetina [1,2], Christopher Monroe [1]

Abstract

Quantum error correction protects fragile quantum information by encoding it into a larger quantum system. These extra degrees of freedom enable the detection and correction of errors, but also increase the operational complexity of the encoded logical qubit. Fault-tolerant circuits contain the spread of errors while operating the logical qubit, and are essential for realizing error suppression in practice. While fault-tolerant design works in principle, it has not previously been demonstrated in an error-corrected physical system with native noise characteristics. In this work, we experimentally demonstrate fault-tolerant preparation, measurement, rotation, and stabilizer measurement of a Bacon-Shor logical qubit using 13 trapped ion qubits. When we compare these fault-tolerant protocols to non-fault tolerant protocols, we see significant reductions in the error rates of the logical primitives in the presence of noise. The result of fault-tolerant design is an average state preparation and measurement error of 0.6% and a Clifford gate error of 0.3% after error correction. Additionally, we prepare magic states with fidelities exceeding the distillation threshold, demonstrating all of the key single-qubit ingredients required for universal fault-tolerant operation. These results demonstrate that fault-tolerant circuits enable highly accurate logical primitives in current quantum systems. With improved two-qubit gates and the use of intermediate measurements, a stabilized logical qubit can be achieved.

Quantum walks and Dirac cellular automata on a programmable trapped-ion quantum computer

C. Huerta Alderete [1,2], Shivani Singh [3,4], Nhung H. Nguyen [1], Daiwei Zhu [1], Radhakrishnan Balu [5,6], Christopher Monroe [1], C. M. Chandrashekar [3,4], Norbert M. Linke [1]

Abstract

The quantum walk formalism is a widely used and highly successful framework for modeling quantum systems, such as simulations of the Dirac equation, different dynamics in both the low and high energy regime, and for developing a wide range of quantum algorithms. Here we present the circuit-based implementation of a discrete-time quantum walk in position space on a five-qubit trapped-ion quantum processor. We encode the space of walker positions in particular multi-qubit states and program the system to operate with different quantum walk parameters, experimentally realizing a Dirac cellular automaton with tunable mass parameter. The quantum walk circuits and position state mapping scale favorably to a larger model and physical systems, allowing the implementation of any algorithm based on discrete-time quantum walks algorithm and the dynamics associated with the discretized version of the Dirac equation.

Noise reduction using past causal cones in variational quantum algorithms

Omar Shehab [1], Isaac H. Kim [2], Nhung H. Nguyen [3], Kevin Landsman [3], Cinthia H. Alderete [3,4], Daiwei Zhu [3], C. Monroe [1,3], Norbert M. Linke [3]

Abstract

We introduce an approach to improve the accuracy and reduce the sample complexity of near term quantum-classical algorithms. We construct a simpler initial parameterized quantum state, or ansatz, based on the past causal cone of each observable, generally yielding fewer qubits and gates. We implement this protocol on a trapped ion quantum computer and demonstrate improvement in accuracy and time-to-solution at an arbitrary point in the variational search space. We report a $\sim 27\%$ improvement in the accuracy of the calculation of the deuteron binding energy and $\sim 40\%$ improvement in the accuracy of the quantum approximate optimization of the MAXCUT problem applied to the dragon graph $T_{3,2}$. When the time-to-solution is prioritized over accuracy, the former requires $\sim 71\%$ fewer measurements and the latter requires $\sim 78\%$ fewer measurements.

Two-qubit entangling gates within arbitrarily long chains of trapped ions

Kevin A. Landsman, Yukai Wu, Pak Hong Leung, Daiwei Zhu, Norbert M. Linke, Kenneth R. Brown, Luming Duan, Christopher R. Monroe

Abstract

Ion trap systems are a leading platform for large scale quantum computers. Trapped ion qubit crystals are fully-connected and reconfigurable, owing to their long range Coulomb interaction that can be modulated with external optical forces. However, the spectral crowding of collective motional modes could pose a challenge to the control of such interactions for large numbers of qubits. Here, we show that high-fidelity quantum gate operations are still possible with very large trapped ion crystals, simplifying the scaling of ion trap quantum computers. To this end, we present analytical work that determines how parallel entangling gates produce a crosstalk error that falls off as the inverse cube of the distance between the pairs. We also show experimental work demonstrating entangling gates on a fully-connected chain of seventeen $^{171}{\rm{Yb}}^{+}$ ions with fidelities as high as $97(1)\%$.

Toward convergence of effective field theory simulations on digital quantum computers

Omar Shehab, Kevin A. Landsman, Yunseong Nam, Daiwei Zhu, Norbert M. Linke, Matthew J. Keesan, Raphael C. Pooser, Christopher R. Monroe

Abstract

We report results for simulating an effective field theory to compute the binding energy of the deuteron nucleus using a hybrid algorithm on a trapped-ion quantum computer. Two increasingly complex unitary coupled-cluster ansaetze have been used to compute the binding energy to within a few percent for successively more complex Hamiltonians. By increasing the complexity of the Hamiltonian, allowing more terms in the effective field theory expansion and calculating their expectation values, we present a benchmark for quantum computers based on their ability to scalably calculate the effective field theory with increasing accuracy. Our result of $E_4=-2.220 \pm 0.179$MeV may be compared with the exact Deuteron ground-state energy $-2.224$MeV. We also demonstrate an error mitigation technique using Richardson extrapolation on ion traps for the first time. The error mitigation circuit represents a record for deepest quantum circuit on a trapped-ion quantum computer.