Dan Gresh

Demonstrating an unconditional separation between quantum and classical information resources

William Kretschmer [1,2], Sabee Grewal [1], Matthew DeCross [3], Justin A. Gerber [3], Kevin Gilmore [3], Dan Gresh [3], Nicholas Hunter-Jones [4,1], Karl Mayer [3], Brian Neyenhuis [3], David Hayes [3], Scott Aaronson [1]

Abstract

A longstanding goal in quantum information science is to demonstrate quantum computations that cannot be feasibly reproduced on a classical computer. Such demonstrations mark major milestones: they showcase fine control over quantum systems and are prerequisites for useful quantum computation. To date, quantum advantage has been demonstrated, for example, through violations of Bell inequalities and sampling-based quantum supremacy experiments. However, both forms of advantage come with important caveats: Bell tests are not computationally difficult tasks, and the classical hardness of sampling experiments relies on unproven complexity-theoretic assumptions. Here we demonstrate an unconditional quantum advantage in information resources required for a computational task, realized on Quantinuum's H1-1 trapped-ion quantum computer operating at a median two-qubit partial-entangler fidelity of 99.941(7)%. We construct a task for which the most space-efficient classical algorithm provably requires between 62 and 382 bits of memory, and solve it using only 12 qubits. Our result provides the most direct evidence yet that currently existing quantum processors can generate and manipulate entangled states of sufficient complexity to access the exponentiality of Hilbert space. This form of quantum advantage -- which we call quantum information supremacy -- represents a new benchmark in quantum computing, one that does not rely on unproven conjectures.

Breaking even with magic: demonstration of a high-fidelity logical non-Clifford gate

Shival Dasu [1], Simon Burton [2], Karl Mayer [1], David Amaro [2], Justin A. Gerber [1], Kevin Gilmore [1], Dan Gresh [1], Davide DelVento [1], Andrew C. Potter [1], David Hayes [1]

Abstract

Encoding quantum information to protect it from errors is essential for performing large-scale quantum computations. Performing a universal set of quantum gates on encoded states demands a potentially large resource overhead and minimizing this overhead is key for the practical development of large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computers. We propose and experimentally implement a magic-state preparation protocol to fault-tolerantly prepare a pair of logical magic states in a [[6,2,2]] quantum error-detecting code using only eight physical qubits. Implementing this protocol on H1-1, a 20 qubit trapped-ion quantum processor, we prepare magic states with experimental infidelity $7^{+3}_{-1}\times 10^{-5}$ with a $14.8^{+1}_{-1}\%$ discard rate and use these to perform a fault-tolerant non-Clifford gate, the controlled-Hadamard (CH), with logical infidelity $\leq 2.3^{+9}_{-9}\times 10^{-4}$. Notably, this significantly outperforms the unencoded physical CH infidelity of $10^{-3}$. Through circuit-level stabilizer simulations, we show that this protocol can be self-concatenated to produce extremely high-fidelity magic states with low space-time overhead in a [[36,4,4]] quantum error correcting code, with logical error rates of $6\times 10^{-10}$ ($5\times 10^{-14}$) at two-qubit error rate of $10^{-3}$ ($10^{-4}$) respectively.

Digital quantum magnetism on a trapped-ion quantum computer

Reza Haghshenas, Eli Chertkov, Michael Mills, Wilhelm Kadow, Sheng-Hsuan Lin, Yi-Hsiang Chen, Chris Cade, Ido Niesen, Tomislav Begušić, Manuel S. Rudolph, Cristina Cirstoiu, Kevin Hemery, Conor Mc Keever, Michael Lubasch, Etienne Granet, Charles H. Baldwin, John P. Bartolotta, Matthew Bohn, Justin J. Burau, Julia Cline, Matthew DeCross, Joan M. Dreiling, Cameron Foltz, David Francois, John P. Gaebler, Christopher N. Gilbreth, Johnnie Gray, Dan Gresh, Alex Hall, Aaron Hankin, Azure Hansen, Nathan Hewitt, Craig A. Holliman, Ross B. Hutson, Mohsin Iqbal, Nikhil Kotibhaskar, Elliot Lehman, Dominic Lucchetti, Ivaylo S. Madjarov, Karl Mayer, Alistair R. Milne, Steven A. Moses, Brian Neyenhuis, Gunhee Park, Abigail R. Perry, Boris Ponsioen, Michael Schecter, Peter E. Siegfried, David T. Stephen, Bruce G. Tiemann, Maxwell D. Urmey, James Walker, Andrew C. Potter, David Hayes, Garnet Kin-Lic Chan, Frank Pollmann, Michael Knap, Henrik Dreyer, Michael Foss-Feig

Abstract

Digital quantum matter -- realized when discrete quantum gates approximate continuous time evolution -- is susceptible to heating into chaotic, structureless states. If digitization errors are adequately suppressed, a long-lived transient regime of approximately energy-conserving dynamics can be observed on gate-based quantum computers. Conservation of energy, in turn, enables the exploration of a wide variety of complex behaviors observed in equilibrium systems, ranging from the nontrivial microscopic origins of thermalization itself to the stabilization of effective models hosting exotic emergent properties. Here, we use Quantinuum's system model H2 quantum computer to simulate digitized dynamics of the quantum Ising model, suppressing digitization errors well enough to observe thermalization on timescales that severely challenge classical simulation methods. Relaxation of an inhomogeneous state reveals an emergent hydrodynamics due to approximate energy conservation, and we compute the associated diffusion constant. By reprogramming our simulations to take place on a triangular lattice with periodic boundary conditions, we observe thermalization consistent with emergent gauge and topological constraints resulting from lattice frustration. Our results were enabled by continued advances in two-qubit gate quality (native partial entangler fidelities of $99.94(1)\%$), and establish digital quantum computers as powerful tools for studying (effectively) continuous-time dynamics.

Qutrit Toric Code and Parafermions in Trapped Ions

Mohsin Iqbal [1], Anasuya Lyons [2], Chiu Fan Bowen Lo [2], Nathanan Tantivasadakarn [3,4], Joan Dreiling, Cameron Foltz [4], Thomas M. Gatterman [4], Dan Gresh [4], Nathan Hewitt [4], Craig A. Holliman [4], Jacob Johansen [4], Brian Neyenhuis [4], Yohei Matsuoka [4], Michael Mills [4], Steven A. Moses [4], Peter Siegfried [4], Ashvin Vishwanath [2], Ruben Verresen [5,2], Henrik Dreyer [1]

Abstract

The development of programmable quantum devices can be measured by the complexity of manybody states that they are able to prepare. Among the most significant are topologically ordered states of matter, which enable robust quantum information storage and processing. While topological orders are more readily accessible with qudits, experimental realisations have thus far been limited to lattice models of qubits. Here, we prepare a ground state of the Z3 toric code state on 24 qutrits in a trapped ion quantum processor with fidelity per qutrit exceeding 96.5(3)%. We manipulate two types of defects which go beyond the conventional qubit toric code: a parafermion, and its bound state which is related to charge conjugation symmetry. We further demonstrate defect fusion and the transfer of entanglement between anyons and defects, which we use to control topological qutrits. Our work opens up the space of long-range entangled states with qudit degrees of freedom for use in quantum simulation and universal error-correcting codes.

Measuring error rates of mid-circuit measurements

Daniel Hothem [1], Jordan Hines [1,2], Charles Baldwin [3], Dan Gresh [3], Robin Blume-Kohout [4], Timothy Proctor [1]

Abstract

High-fidelity mid-circuit measurements, which read out the state of specific qubits in a multiqubit processor without destroying them or disrupting their neighbors, are a critical component for useful quantum computing. They enable fault-tolerant quantum error correction, dynamic circuits, and other paths to solving classically intractable problems. But there are almost no methods to assess their performance comprehensively. We address this gap by introducing the first randomized benchmarking protocol that measures the rate at which mid-circuit measurements induce errors in many-qubit circuits. Using this protocol, we detect and eliminate previously undetected measurement-induced crosstalk in a 20-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer. Then, we use the same protocol to measure the rate of measurement-induced crosstalk error on a 27-qubit IBM Q processor, and quantify how much of that error is eliminated by dynamical decoupling.

Experimental Demonstration of Break-Even for the Compact Fermionic Encoding

Ramil Nigmatullin [1], Kevin Hemery [1], Khaldoon Ghanem [1], Steven Moses [2], Dan Gresh [2], Peter Siegfried [2], Michael Mills [2], Thomas Gatterman [2], Nathan Hewitt [2], Etienne Granet [1], Henrik Dreyer [1]

Abstract

The utility of solving the Fermi-Hubbard model has been estimated in the billions of dollars. Digital quantum computers can in principle address this task, but have so far been limited to quasi one-dimensional models. This is because of exponential overheads caused by the interplay of noise and the non-locality of the mapping between fermions and qubits. Here, we show experimentally that a recently developed local encoding can overcome this problem. We develop a new compilation scheme, called "corner hopping", that reduces the cost of simulating fermionic hopping by 42% which allows us to conduct the largest digital quantum simulations of a fermionic model to date, using a trapped ion quantum computer to prepare adiabatically the ground state of a 6 x 6 spinless Fermi-Hubbard model encoded in 48 physical qubits. We also develop two new error mitigation schemes for systems with conserved quantities, one based on local postselection and one on extrapolation of local observables. Our results suggest that Fermi-Hubbard models beyond classical simulability can be addressed by digital quantum computers without large increases in gate fidelity.

Demonstration of quantum computation and error correction with a tesseract code

Ben W. Reichardt [3], David Aasen, Rui Chao, Alex Chernoguzov, Wim van Dam, John P. Gaebler, Dan Gresh, Dominic Lucchetti, Michael Mills, Steven A. Moses, Brian Neyenhuis, Adam Paetznick, Andres Paz, Peter E. Siegfried, Marcus P. da Silva, Krysta M. Svore, Zhenghan Wang, Matt Zanner

Abstract

A critical milestone for quantum computers is to demonstrate fault-tolerant computation that outperforms computation on physical qubits. The tesseract subsystem color code protects four logical qubits in 16 physical qubits, to distance four. Using the tesseract code on Quantinuum's trapped-ion quantum computers, we prepare high-fidelity encoded graph states on up to 12 logical qubits, beneficially combining for the first time fault-tolerant error correction and computation. We also protect encoded states through up to five rounds of error correction. Using performant quantum software and hardware together allows moderate-depth logical quantum circuits to have an order of magnitude less error than the equivalent unencoded circuits.

Experiments with the 4D Surface Code on a QCCD Quantum Computer

Noah Berthusen [1,2], Joan Dreiling [2], Cameron Foltz [2], John P. Gaebler [2], Thomas M. Gatterman [2], Dan Gresh [2], Nathan Hewitt [2], Michael Mills [2], Steven A. Moses [2], Brian Neyenhuis [2], Peter Siegfried [2], David Hayes [2]

Abstract

Single-shot quantum error correction has the potential to speed up quantum computations by removing the need for multiple rounds of syndrome extraction in order to be fault-tolerant. Using Quantinuum's H2 trapped-ion quantum computer, we implement the [[33,1,4]] 4D surface code and perform the first experimental demonstration of single-shot quantum error correction with bare ancilla qubits. We conduct memory experiments comparing the 2D and 4D surface codes and find that despite differences in qubit use and syndrome extraction circuit depth, the 4D surface code matches or outperforms the 2D surface code in both the fault-tolerant and single-shot regimes.

Benchmarking logical three-qubit quantum Fourier transform encoded in the Steane code on a trapped-ion quantum computer

Karl Mayer, Ciarán Ryan-Anderson, Natalie Brown, Elijah Durso-Sabina, Charles H. Baldwin, David Hayes, Joan M. Dreiling, Cameron Foltz, John P. Gaebler, Thomas M. Gatterman, Justin A. Gerber, Kevin Gilmore, Dan Gresh, Nathan Hewitt, Chandler V. Horst, Jacob Johansen, Tanner Mengle, Michael Mills, Steven A. Moses, Peter E. Siegfried, Brian Neyenhuis, Juan Pino, Russell Stutz [15]

Abstract

We implement logically encoded three-qubit circuits for the quantum Fourier transform (QFT), using the [[7,1,3]] Steane code, and benchmark the circuits on the Quantinuum H2-1 trapped-ion quantum computer. The circuits require multiple logical two-qubit gates, which are implemented transversally, as well as logical non-Clifford single-qubit rotations, which are performed by non-fault-tolerant state preparation followed by a teleportation gadget. First, we benchmark individual logical components using randomized benchmarking for the logical two-qubit gate, and a Ramsey-type experiment for the logical $T$ gate. We then implement the full QFT circuit, using two different methods for performing a logical control-$T$, and benchmark the circuits by applying it to each basis state in a set of bases that is sufficient to lower bound the process fidelity. We compare the logical QFT benchmark results to predictions based on the logical component benchmarks.

Evidence of Scaling Advantage for the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm on a Classically Intractable Problem

Ruslan Shaydulin [1], Changhao Li [1], Shouvanik Chakrabarti [1], Matthew DeCross [2], Dylan Herman [1], Niraj Kumar [1], Jeffrey Larson [3], Danylo Lykov [1,4], Pierre Minssen [1], Yue Sun [1], Yuri Alexeev [4], Joan M. Dreiling [2], John P. Gaebler [2], Thomas M. Gatterman [2], Justin A. Gerber [2], Kevin Gilmore [2], Dan Gresh [2], Nathan Hewitt [2], Chandler V. Horst [2], Shaohan Hu [1], Jacob Johansen [2], Mitchell Matheny [2], Tanner Mengle [2], Michael Mills [2], Steven A. Moses [2], Brian Neyenhuis [2], Peter Siegfried [2], Romina Yalovetzky [1], Marco Pistoia [1]

Abstract

The quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) is a leading candidate algorithm for solving optimization problems on quantum computers. However, the potential of QAOA to tackle classically intractable problems remains unclear. Here, we perform an extensive numerical investigation of QAOA on the low autocorrelation binary sequences (LABS) problem, which is classically intractable even for moderately sized instances. We perform noiseless simulations with up to 40 qubits and observe that the runtime of QAOA with fixed parameters scales better than branch-and-bound solvers, which are the state-of-the-art exact solvers for LABS. The combination of QAOA with quantum minimum finding gives the best empirical scaling of any algorithm for the LABS problem. We demonstrate experimental progress in executing QAOA for the LABS problem using an algorithm-specific error detection scheme on Quantinuum trapped-ion processors. Our results provide evidence for the utility of QAOA as an algorithmic component that enables quantum speedups.

Topological Order from Measurements and Feed-Forward on a Trapped Ion Quantum Computer

Mohsin Iqbal [1], Nathanan Tantivasadakarn [2], Thomas M. Gatterman [3], Justin A. Gerber [3], Kevin Gilmore [3], Dan Gresh [3], Aaron Hankin [3], Nathan Hewitt [3], Chandler V. Horst [3], Mitchell Matheny [3], Tanner Mengle [3], Brian Neyenhuis [3], Ashvin Vishwanath [4], Michael Foss-Feig [3], Ruben Verresen [4], Henrik Dreyer [1]

Abstract

Quantum systems evolve in time in one of two ways: through the Schrödinger equation or wavefunction collapse. So far, deterministic control of quantum many-body systems in the lab has focused on the former, due to the probabilistic nature of measurements. This imposes serious limitations: preparing long-range entangled states, for example, requires extensive circuit depth if restricted to unitary dynamics. In this work, we use mid-circuit measurement and feed-forward to implement deterministic non-unitary dynamics on Quantinuum's H1 programmable ion-trap quantum computer. Enabled by these capabilities, we demonstrate for the first time a constant-depth procedure for creating a toric code ground state in real-time. In addition to reaching high stabilizer fidelities, we create a non-Abelian defect whose presence is confirmed by transmuting anyons via braiding. This work clears the way towards creating complex topological orders in the lab and exploring deterministic non-unitary dynamics via measurement and feed-forward.

Holographic dynamics simulations with a trapped ion quantum computer

Eli Chertkov [2], Justin Bohnet, David Francois, John Gaebler, Dan Gresh, Aaron Hankin, Kenny Lee, Ra'anan Tobey, David Hayes, Brian Neyenhuis, Russell Stutz, Andrew C. Potter [3], Michael Foss-Feig

Abstract

Quantum computers have the potential to efficiently simulate the dynamics of many interacting quantum particles, a classically intractable task of central importance to fields ranging from chemistry to high-energy physics. However, precision and memory limitations of existing hardware severely limit the size and complexity of models that can be simulated with conventional methods. Here, we demonstrate and benchmark a new scalable quantum simulation paradigm--holographic quantum dynamics simulation--which uses efficient quantum data compression afforded by quantum tensor networks along with opportunistic mid-circuit measurement and qubit reuse to simulate physical systems that have far more quantum degrees of freedom than can be captured by the available number of qubits. Using a Honeywell trapped ion quantum processor, we simulate the non-integrable (chaotic) dynamics of the self-dual kicked Ising model starting from an entangled state of $32$ spins using at most $9$ trapped ion qubits, obtaining excellent quantitative agreement when benchmarking against dynamics computed directly in the thermodynamic limit via recently developed exact analytical techniques. These results suggest that quantum tensor network methods, together with state-of-the-art quantum processor capabilities, enable a viable path to practical quantum advantage in the near term.