Klaus Blaum

Half-life Measurements of Highly Charged Radioisotopes by Nuclear Recoil in a Penning Trap

Scott Moroch [1], Carolyn Chun [1], Doug VanDerwerken [2], Ariana Shearin [1], Brian Beaudoin, Klaus Blaum [3], Timothy Koeth

Abstract

We present a novel method for measuring the half-life of highly charged radioisotopes by non-destructive nuclear recoil detection in a Penning ion trap. A specific emphasis is placed on $\rm ^7Be^{3+}$, which plays a crucial role in stellar evolution and the production of solar neutrinos. The determination of the half-life is necessary to constrain the free electron capture rate in the solar environment, but is difficult to measure by existing techniques. Simulations of the sympathetic cooling of the recoiled daughter nuclei ($\rm ^7Li^{3+}$) with the trapped cloud of $\rm ^7Be^{3+}$ demonstrate a decay detection efficiency of $99.5\%$. A statistical analysis of half-life measurements on ensembles containing hundreds of ions shows that a final statistical uncertainty of less than $5\%$ is achieved with only 500 measured decays. By coherent control of hyperfine populations in trapped ions, the fidelity of the technique we describe enables the direct measurement and manipulation of state-dependent decay branching ratios for the first time.

Penning-trap measurement of the $Q$-value of the electron capture in $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$ for the determination of the electron neutrino mass

Christoph Schweiger [1,2], Martin Braß, Vincent Debierre [1], Menno Door [1], Holger Dorrer [3,4,5], Christoph E. Düllmann, Christian Enss [6], Pavel Filianin [1], Loredana Gastaldo [6,1], Zoltán Harman, Maurits W. Haverkort [2], Jost Herkenhoff [1], Paul Indelicato [7], Christoph H. Keitel [1], Kathrin Kromer [1], Daniel Lange [1,8], Yuri N. Novikov [9], Dennis Renisch [3,4], Alexander Rischka [1], Rima X. Schüssler, Sergey Eliseev [1], Klaus Blaum [1]

Abstract

The investigation of the absolute scale of the effective neutrino mass remains challenging due to the exclusively weak interaction of neutrinos with all known particles in the standard model of particle physics. Currently, the most precise and least model-dependent upper limit on the electron antineutrino mass is set by the KATRIN experiment from the analysis of the tritium \b{eta}-decay. Another promising approach is the electron capture in $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$, which is under investigation using microcalorimetry within the ECHo and HOLMES collab orations. An independently measured Q-value of this process is vital for the assessment of systematic uncertainties in the neutrino mass determination. Here, we report a direct, independent determination of this $Q$-value by measuring the free-space cyclotron frequency ratio of highly charged ions of $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$ and $^{163}\mathrm{Dy}$ in the Penning trap experiment \textsc{Pentatrap}. Combining this ratio with atomic physics calculations of the electronic binding energies yields a $Q$-value of $2863.2(0.6)\,\mathrm{eV}/c^{2}$ - a more than 50-fold improvement over the state-of-the-art. This will enable the determination of the electron neutrino mass on a sub-eV level from the analysis of the electron capture in $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$.

Atomic mass determination of uranium-238

Kathrin Kromer [1], Chunhai Lyu [1,2], Jacek Bieroń, Menno Door [1], Lucia Enzmann [1,3], Pavel Filianin [1], Gediminas Gaigalas [4,1], Zoltán Harman, Jost Herkenhoff [1], Wenjia Huang [5], Christoph H. Keitel [1], Sergey Eliseev [1], Klaus Blaum [1]

Abstract

The atomic mass of uranium-238 has been determined to be $238.050\,787\,618(15)\,\text{u}$, improving the literature uncertainty by two orders of magnitude. It is obtained from a measurement of the mass ratio of $^{238}$U$^{47+}$ and $^{132}$Xe$^{26+}$ ions with an uncertainty of $3.5\times 10^{-12}$. The measurement was carried out with the Penning-trap mass spectrometer \textsc{Pentatrap} and was accompanied by a calculation of the binding energies $E_{\text{U}}$ and $E_{\text{Xe}}$ of the 47 and 26 missing electrons of the two highly charged ions, respectively. These binding energies were determined using an \textit{ab initio} multiconfiguration Dirac-Hartree-Fock (MCDHF) method to be $E_{\text{U}} = 39\,927(10)\,\text{eV}$ and $E_{\text{Xe}} = 8\,971.2(21)\,\text{eV}$. The new mass value will serve as a reference for high-precision mass measurements in the heavy mass region of the nuclear chart up to transuranium nuclides.

Fast Silicon Carbide MOSFET based high-voltage push-pull switch for charge state separation of highly charged ions with a Bradbury-Nielsen Gate

Christoph Schweiger, Menno Door, Pavel Filianin, Jost Herkenhoff, Kathrin Kromer, Daniel Lange, Domenik Marschall [1], Alexander Rischka [1], Thomas Wagner [1], Sergey Eliseev [1], Klaus Blaum [1]

Abstract

In this paper we report on the development of a fast high-voltage switch, which is based on two enhancement mode N-channel Silicon Carbide Metal Oxide Semiconductor Field-Effect Transistors in push-pull configuration. The switch is capable of switching high voltages up to 600 V on capacitive loads with rise and fall times on the order of 10 ns and pulse widths $\leq$ 20 ns. Using this switch it was demonstrated that from the charge state distribution of bunches of highly charged ions ejected from an electron beam ion trap with a specific kinetic energy, single charge states can be separated by fast switching of the high voltage applied to a Bradbury-Nielsen Gate with a resolving power of about 100.

Penning-Trap Mass Measurement of Helium-4

Sangeetha Sasidharan, Olesia Bezrodnova, Sascha Rau, Wolfgang Quint, Sven Sturm, Klaus Blaum

Abstract

Light-Ion Trap (LIONTRAP), a high-precision Penning-trap mass spectrometer, was used to determine the atomic mass of $^{4}$He. Here, we report a 12 parts-per-trillion measurement of the mass of a $^{4}$He$^{2+}$ ion, $m(^{4}\text{He}^{2+}$) = $4.001\:506\:179\:651 (48)$ u. From this, the atomic mass of the neutral atom can be determined without loss of precision: $m(^{4}\text{He})$ = $4.002\:603\:254\:653 (48)$ u. This result is slightly more precise than the current CODATA18 literature value but deviates by 6.6 standard deviations. This is a post-peer-review, pre-copy edit version of an article published in PRL. The final version is available online at https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.131.093201.

Observation of a low-lying metastable electronic state in highly charged lead by Penning-trap mass spectrometry

Kathrin Kromer [1], Chunhai Lyu [1], Menno Door [1], Pavel Filianin [1], Zoltán Harman, Jost Herkenhoff [1], Paul Indelicato [2], Christoph H. Keitel [1], Daniel Lange [1], Yuri N. Novikov [3,4], Christoph Schweiger [1], Sergey Eliseev [1], Klaus Blaum [1]

Abstract

Highly charged ions (HCIs) offer many opportunities for next-generation clock research due to the vast landscape of available electronic transitions in different charge states. The development of XUV frequency combs has enabled the search for clock transitions based on shorter wavelengths in HCIs. However, without initial knowledge of the energy of the clock states, these narrow transitions are difficult to be probed by lasers. In this Letter, we provide experimental observation and theoretical calculation of a long-lived electronic state in Nb-like Pb$^{41+}$ which could be used as a clock state. With the mass spectrometer Pentatrap, the excitation energy of this metastable state is directly determined as a mass difference at an energy of 31.2(8) eV, corresponding to one of the most precise relative mass determinations to date with a fractional uncertainty of $4\times10^{-12}$. This experimental result agrees within 1 $σ$ with two partially different \textit{ab initio} multi-configuration Dirac-Hartree-Fock calculations of 31.68(13) eV and 31.76(35) eV, respectively. With a calculated lifetime of 26.5(5.3) days, the transition from this metastable state to the ground state bears a quality factor of $1.1\times10^{23}$ and allows for the construction of a HCI clock with a fractional frequency instability of $<10^{-19}/\sqrtτ$.

Electroweak Nuclear Properties from Single Molecular Ions in a Penning Trap

Jonas Karthein, Silviu-Marian Udrescu, Scott B. Moroch, Ivana Belosevic, Klaus Blaum, Anastasia Borschevsky, Yuly Chamorro, David DeMille, Jens Dilling, Ronald F. Garcia Ruiz, Nick R. Hutzler, Lukáš F. Pašteka, Ryan Ringle

Abstract

We present a novel technique to probe electroweak nuclear properties by measuring parity violation (PV) in single molecular ions in a Penning trap. The trap's strong magnetic field Zeeman shifts opposite-parity rotational and hyperfine molecular states into near degeneracy. The weak interaction-induced mixing between these degenerate states can be larger than in atoms by more than twelve orders of magnitude, thereby vastly amplifying PV effects. The single molecule sensitivity would be suitable for applications to nuclei across the nuclear chart, including rare and unstable nuclei.

Trap-integrated fluorescence detection based on silicon photomultipliers in a cryogenic Penning trap

Markus Wiesinger, Florian Stuhlmann, Matthew A. Bohman, Peter Micke, Christian Will, Hüseyin Yildiz, Fatma Abbass, Bela P. Arndt, Jack A. Devlin, Stefan Erlewein, Markus Fleck, Julia I. Jäger, Barbara M. Latacz, Daniel Schweitzer, Gilbertas Umbrazunas, Elise Wursten, Klaus Blaum, Yasuyuki Matsuda, Andreas Mooser, Wolfgang Quint, Anna Soter, Jochen Walz, Christian Smorra, Stefan Ulmer

Abstract

We present a fluorescence-detection system for laser-cooled 9Be+ ions based on silicon photomultipliers (SiPM) operated at 4 K and integrated into our cryogenic 1.9 T multi-Penning-trap system. Our approach enables fluorescence detection in a hermetically-sealed cryogenic Penning-trap chamber with limited optical access, where state-of-the-art detection using a telescope and photomultipliers at room temperature would be extremely difficult. We characterize the properties of the SiPM in a cryocooler at 4 K, where we measure a dark count rate below 1/s and a detection efficiency of 2.5(3) %. We further discuss the design of our cryogenic fluorescence-detection trap, and analyze the performance of our detection system by fluorescence spectroscopy of 9Be+ ion clouds during several runs of our experiment.

Direct Bound-Electron $g$ factor Difference Measurement with Coupled Ions

Tim Sailer [1], Vincent Debierre [1], Zoltán Harman, Fabian Heiße, Charlotte König, Jonathan Morgner [1], Bingsheng Tu [1], Andrey V. Volotka [2,3], Christoph H. Keitel [1], Klaus Blaum [1], Sven Sturm [1]

Abstract

The quantum electrodynamic (QED) description of light-and-matter interaction is one of the most fundamental theories of physics and has been shown to be in excellent agreement with experimental results. Specifically, measurements of the electronic magnetic moment (or $g$ factor) of highly charged ions (HCI) in Penning traps can provide a stringent probe for QED, testing the Standard model in the strongest electromagnetic fields. When studying the difference of isotopes, even the intricate effects stemming from the nucleus can be resolved and tested as, due to the identical electron configuration, many common QED contributions do not have to be considered. Experimentally however, this becomes quickly limited, particularly by the precision of the ion masses or the achievable magnetic field stability. Here we report on a novel measurement technique that overcomes both of these limitations by co-trapping two HCIs in a Penning trap and measuring the difference of their $g$ factors directly. The resulting correlation of magnetic field fluctuations leads to drastically higher precision. We use a dual Ramsey-type measurement scheme with the ions locked on a common magnetron orbit, separated by only a few hundred micrometres, to extract the coherent spin precession frequency difference. We have measured the isotopic shift of the bound electron $g$ factor of the neon isotopes of $^{20}$Ne$^{9+}$ and $^{22}$Ne$^{9+}$ to 0.56 parts-per-trillion ($5.6 \cdot 10^{-13}$) precision relative to their $g$ factors, which is an improvement of more than two orders of magnitude compared to state-of-the-art techniques. This resolves the QED contribution to the nuclear recoil for the very first time and accurately validates the corresponding theory. Furthermore, the agreement with theory allows setting constraints for a fifth-force, resulting from Higgs-portal-type dark-matter interactions.

Perspectives on testing fundamental physics with highly charged ions in Penning traps

Klaus Blaum, Sergey Eliseev, Sven Sturm

Abstract

In Penning traps electromagnetic forces are used to confine charged particles under well-controlled conditions for virtually unlimited time. Sensitive detection methods have been developed to allow observation of single stored ions. Various cooling methods can be employed to reduce the energy of the trapped particle to nearly at rest. In this review we summarize how highly charged ions offer unique possibilities for precision measurements in Penning traps. Precision atomic and nuclear masses as well as magnetic moments of bound electrons allow among others to determine fundamental constants like the mass of the electron or to perform stringent tests of fundamental interactions like bound-state quantum electrodynamics. Recent results and future perspectives in high-precision Penning-trap spectroscopy with highly charged ions will be discussed.

Penning-trap mass measurements of the deuteron and the HD+ molecular ion

Sascha Rau [1,2], Fabian Heiße, Florian Köhler-Langes, Sangeetha Sasidharan [1,2], Raphael Haas [2,3,4,5], Dennis Renisch [3,4,2,5], Christoph E. Düllmann, Wolfgang Quint [2], Sven Sturm [1], Klaus Blaum [1]

Abstract

The masses of the lightest atomic nuclei and the electron mass are interlinked and are crucial in a wide range of research fields, with their values affecting observables in atomic, molecular and neutrino physics as well as metrology. The most precise values for these fundamental parameters come from Penning-trap mass spectrometry, which achieves relative mass uncertainties in the range of $10^{-11}$. However, redundancy checks using data from different experiments reveal significant inconsistencies in the masses of the proton ($m_p$), the deuteron ($m_d$) and helion ($m_\text{he}$), amounting to $5$ standard deviations for the term $Δ=m_p+m_d-m_{\text{he}}$, which suggests that the uncertainty of these values may have been underestimated. Here we present results from absolute mass measurements of the deuteron and the ${HD}^+$ molecular ion against $^{12}C$ as a mass reference. Our value for the deuteron $m_d=2.013\,553\,212\,535 (17)$u supersedes the precision of the literature value by a factor of $2.4$ and deviates from this by $4.8$ standard deviations. With a relative uncertainty of $8$ parts per trillion (ppt) this is the most precise mass value measured directly in atomic mass units. Furthermore, the measurement of the ${HD}^+$ molecular ion, $m({HD}^+)=3.021\,378\,241\,561\,(61)$u, not only allows for a rigorous consistency check of our measurements of the masses of the deuteron (this work) and proton, but also establishes an additional link for the masses of tritium and helium-3 to the atomic mass unit. Combined with a recent measurement of the deuteron-to-proton mass ratio the uncertainty of the reference value of $m_p$ can be reduced by a factor of three. This is a post-peer-review, pre-copyedit version of an article published in Nature. The final authenticated version is available online at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2628-7

A Digital Feedback System for Advanced Ion Manipulation Techniques in Penning Traps

Jost Herkenhoff [1], Menno Door [1], Pavel Filianin [1], Wenjia Huang [1], Kathrin Kromer [1], Daniel Lange [1,2], Rima X. Schüssler, Christoph Schweiger [1], Sergey Eliseev [1], Klaus Blaum [1]

Abstract

The possibility to apply active feedback to a single ion in a Penning trap using a fully digital system is demonstrated. Previously realized feedback systems rely on analog circuits that are susceptible to environmental fluctuations and long term drifts, as well as being limited to the specific task they were designed for. The presented system is implemented using an FPGA-based platform (STEMlab), offering greater flexibility, higher temporal stability and the possibility for highly dynamic variation of feedback parameters. The system's capabilities were demonstrated by applying feedback to the ion detection system primarily consisting of a resonant circuit. This allowed shifts in its resonance frequency of up to several kHz and free modification of its quality factor within two orders of magnitude, which reduces the temperature of a single ion by a factor of 6. Furthermore, a phase-sensitive detection technique for the axial ion oscillation was implemented, which reduces the current measurement time by two orders of magnitude while simultaneously eliminating model-related systematic uncertainties. The use of FPGA technology allowed the implementation of a fully-featured data acquisition system, making it possible to realize feedback techniques that require constant monitoring of the ion signal. This was successfully used to implement a single-ion self-excited oscillator.

Detection of metastable electronic states by Penning trap mass spectrometry

Rima Xenia Schüssler, Hendrik Bekker, Martin Braß, Halil Cakir, José R. Crespo López-Urrutia, Menno Door, Pavel Filianin, Zoltan Harman, Maurits W. Haverkort, Wen Jia Huang, Paul Indelicato, Christoph Helmut Keitel, Charlotte Maria König, Kathrin Kromer, Marius Müller, Yuri N. Novikov, Alexander Rischka, Christoph Schweiger, Sven Sturm, Stefan Ulmer, Ssergey Eliseev, Klaus Blaum

Abstract

State-of-the-art optical clocks achieve fractional precisions of $10^{-18}$ and below using ensembles of atoms in optical lattices or individual ions in radio-frequency traps. Promising candidates for novel clocks are highly charged ions (HCIs) and nuclear transitions, which are largely insensitive to external perturbations and reach wavelengths beyond the optical range, now becoming accessible to frequency combs. However, insufficiently accurate atomic structure calculations still hinder the identification of suitable transitions in HCIs. Here, we report on the discovery of a long-lived metastable electronic state in a HCI by measuring the mass difference of the ground and the excited state in Re, the first non-destructive, direct determination of an electronic excitation energy. This result agrees with our advanced calculations, and we confirmed them with an Os ion with the same electronic configuration. We used the high-precision Penning-trap mass spectrometer PENTATRAP, unique in its synchronous use of five individual traps for simultaneous mass measurements. The cyclotron frequency ratio $R$ of the ion in the ground state to the metastable state could be determined to a precision of $δR=1\cdot 10^{-11}$, unprecedented in the heavy atom regime. With a lifetime of about 130 days, the potential soft x-ray frequency reference at $ν=4.86\cdot 10^{16}\,\text{Hz}$ has a linewidth of only $Δν\approx 5\cdot 10^{-8}\,\text{Hz}$, and one of the highest electronic quality factor ($Q=\fracν{Δν}\approx 10^{24}$) ever seen in an experiment. Our low uncertainty enables searching for more HCI soft x-ray clock transitions, needed for promising precision studies of fundamental physics in a thus far unexplored frontier.

High-precision mass spectrometer for light ions

Fabian Heiße, Sascha Rau, Florian Köhler-Langes, Wolfgang Quint, Günter Werth, Sven Sturm, Klaus Blaum

Abstract

The precise knowledge of the atomic masses of light atomic nuclei, e.g. the proton, deuteron, triton and helion, is of great importance for several fundamental tests in physics. However, the latest high-precision measurements of these masses carried out at different mass spectrometers indicate an inconsistency of five standard deviations. To determine the masses of the lightest ions with a relative precision of a few parts per trillion and investigate this mass problem a cryogenic multi-Penning trap setup, LIONTRAP (Light ION TRAP), was constructed. This allows an independent and more precise determination of the relevant atomic masses by measuring the cyclotron frequency of single trapped ions in comparison to that of a single carbon ion. In this paper the measurement concept and the first doubly compensated cylindrical electrode Penning trap, are presented. Moreover, the analysis of the first measurement campaigns of the proton's and oxygen's atomic mass is described in detail, resulting in mp = 1.007 276 466 598 (33) u and m(16O)= 15.994 914 619 37 (87) u. The results on these data sets have already been presented in [F. Heisse et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 033001 (2017)]. For the proton's atomic mass, the uncertainty was improved by a factor of three compared to the 2014 CODATA value.

Production of highly charged ions of rare species by laser-induced desorption inside an electron beam ion trap

Christoph Schweiger, Charlotte König, José R. Crespo López-Urrutia, Menno Door, Holger Dorrer, Christoph E. Düllmann, Sergey Eliseev, Pavel Filianin, Wenjia Huang, Kathrin Kromer, Peter Micke, Marius Müller, Dennis Renisch, Alexander Rischka, Rima X. Schüssler, Klaus Blaum

Abstract

This paper reports on the development and testing of a novel, highly efficient technique for the injection of very rare species into electron beam ion traps (EBITs) for the production of highly charged ions (HCI). It relies on in-trap laser-induced desorption of atoms from a sample brought very close to the electron beam resulting in a very high capture efficiency in the EBIT. We have demonstrated a steady production of HCI of the stable isotope $^{165}\mathrm{Ho}$ from samples of only $10^{12}$ atoms ($\sim$ 300 pg) in charge states up to 45+. HCI of these species can be subsequently extracted for use in other experiments or stored in the trapping volume of the EBIT for spectroscopic measurements. The high efficiency of this technique expands the range of rare isotope HCIs available for high-precision nuclear mass and spectroscopic measurements. A first application of this technique is the production of HCI of the synthetic radioisotope $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$ for a high-precision measurement of the $Q_{\mathrm{EC}}$-value of the electron capture in $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$ within the Electron Capture in Holmium experiment (ECHo collaboration) ultimately leading to a measurement of the electron neutrino mass with an uncertainty on the sub-eV level.

Long-term monitoring of the internal energy distribution of isolated cluster systems

Christian Breitenfeldt [1,2], Klaus Blaum [2], Sebastian George [2,3], Jürgen Göck, Gregorio Guzmán-Ramírez, Jonas Karthein [2], Thomas Kolling, Michael Lange [2], Sebastian Menk [2], Christian Meyer [2], Jennifer Mohrbach, Gereon Niedner-Schatteburg, Dirk Schwalm [2,5], Lutz Schweikhard [1], Andreas Wolf [2]

Abstract

A method is presented to monitor the internal energy distribution of cluster anions via delayed electron detachment by pulsed photoexcitation and demonstrated on Co$_4{}^-$ in an electrostatic ion beam trap. In cryogenic operation, we calibrate the detachment delay to internal energy. By laser frequency scans, at room temperature, we reconstruct the time-dependent internal energy distribution of the clusters. The mean energies of ensembles from a cold and a hot ion source both approach thermal equilibrium. Our data yield a radiative emission law and the absorptivity of the cluster for thermal radiation.

The electron mass from $g$-factor measurements on hydrogen-like carbon $^{12}$C$^{5+}$

Florian Köhler, Sven Sturm, Anke Kracke, Günter Werth, Wolfgang Quint, Klaus Blaum

Abstract

The electron mass in atomic mass units has been determined with a relative uncertainty of $2.8\cdot 10^{-11}$, which represents a 13-fold improvement of the 2010 CODATA value. The underlying measurement principle combines a high-precision measurement of the Larmor-to-cyclotron frequency ratio on a single hydrogen-like carbon ion in a Penning trap with a corresponding very accurate $g$-factor calculation. Here, we present the measurement results in detail, including a comprehensive discussion of the systematic shifts and their uncertainties. A special focus is set on the various sources of phase jitters, which are essential for the understanding of the applied line-shape model for the $g$-factor resonance.