Paul Indelicato

Penning-trap measurement of the $Q$-value of the electron capture in $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$ for the determination of the electron neutrino mass

Christoph Schweiger [1,2], Martin Braß, Vincent Debierre [1], Menno Door [1], Holger Dorrer [3,4,5], Christoph E. Düllmann, Christian Enss [6], Pavel Filianin [1], Loredana Gastaldo [6,1], Zoltán Harman, Maurits W. Haverkort [2], Jost Herkenhoff [1], Paul Indelicato [7], Christoph H. Keitel [1], Kathrin Kromer [1], Daniel Lange [1,8], Yuri N. Novikov [9], Dennis Renisch [3,4], Alexander Rischka [1], Rima X. Schüssler, Sergey Eliseev [1], Klaus Blaum [1]

Abstract

The investigation of the absolute scale of the effective neutrino mass remains challenging due to the exclusively weak interaction of neutrinos with all known particles in the standard model of particle physics. Currently, the most precise and least model-dependent upper limit on the electron antineutrino mass is set by the KATRIN experiment from the analysis of the tritium \b{eta}-decay. Another promising approach is the electron capture in $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$, which is under investigation using microcalorimetry within the ECHo and HOLMES collab orations. An independently measured Q-value of this process is vital for the assessment of systematic uncertainties in the neutrino mass determination. Here, we report a direct, independent determination of this $Q$-value by measuring the free-space cyclotron frequency ratio of highly charged ions of $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$ and $^{163}\mathrm{Dy}$ in the Penning trap experiment \textsc{Pentatrap}. Combining this ratio with atomic physics calculations of the electronic binding energies yields a $Q$-value of $2863.2(0.6)\,\mathrm{eV}/c^{2}$ - a more than 50-fold improvement over the state-of-the-art. This will enable the determination of the electron neutrino mass on a sub-eV level from the analysis of the electron capture in $^{163}\mathrm{Ho}$.

Observation of a low-lying metastable electronic state in highly charged lead by Penning-trap mass spectrometry

Kathrin Kromer [1], Chunhai Lyu [1], Menno Door [1], Pavel Filianin [1], Zoltán Harman, Jost Herkenhoff [1], Paul Indelicato [2], Christoph H. Keitel [1], Daniel Lange [1], Yuri N. Novikov [3,4], Christoph Schweiger [1], Sergey Eliseev [1], Klaus Blaum [1]

Abstract

Highly charged ions (HCIs) offer many opportunities for next-generation clock research due to the vast landscape of available electronic transitions in different charge states. The development of XUV frequency combs has enabled the search for clock transitions based on shorter wavelengths in HCIs. However, without initial knowledge of the energy of the clock states, these narrow transitions are difficult to be probed by lasers. In this Letter, we provide experimental observation and theoretical calculation of a long-lived electronic state in Nb-like Pb$^{41+}$ which could be used as a clock state. With the mass spectrometer Pentatrap, the excitation energy of this metastable state is directly determined as a mass difference at an energy of 31.2(8) eV, corresponding to one of the most precise relative mass determinations to date with a fractional uncertainty of $4\times10^{-12}$. This experimental result agrees within 1 $σ$ with two partially different \textit{ab initio} multi-configuration Dirac-Hartree-Fock calculations of 31.68(13) eV and 31.76(35) eV, respectively. With a calculated lifetime of 26.5(5.3) days, the transition from this metastable state to the ground state bears a quality factor of $1.1\times10^{23}$ and allows for the construction of a HCI clock with a fractional frequency instability of $<10^{-19}/\sqrtτ$.

Detection of metastable electronic states by Penning trap mass spectrometry

Rima Xenia Schüssler, Hendrik Bekker, Martin Braß, Halil Cakir, José R. Crespo López-Urrutia, Menno Door, Pavel Filianin, Zoltan Harman, Maurits W. Haverkort, Wen Jia Huang, Paul Indelicato, Christoph Helmut Keitel, Charlotte Maria König, Kathrin Kromer, Marius Müller, Yuri N. Novikov, Alexander Rischka, Christoph Schweiger, Sven Sturm, Stefan Ulmer, Ssergey Eliseev, Klaus Blaum

Abstract

State-of-the-art optical clocks achieve fractional precisions of $10^{-18}$ and below using ensembles of atoms in optical lattices or individual ions in radio-frequency traps. Promising candidates for novel clocks are highly charged ions (HCIs) and nuclear transitions, which are largely insensitive to external perturbations and reach wavelengths beyond the optical range, now becoming accessible to frequency combs. However, insufficiently accurate atomic structure calculations still hinder the identification of suitable transitions in HCIs. Here, we report on the discovery of a long-lived metastable electronic state in a HCI by measuring the mass difference of the ground and the excited state in Re, the first non-destructive, direct determination of an electronic excitation energy. This result agrees with our advanced calculations, and we confirmed them with an Os ion with the same electronic configuration. We used the high-precision Penning-trap mass spectrometer PENTATRAP, unique in its synchronous use of five individual traps for simultaneous mass measurements. The cyclotron frequency ratio $R$ of the ion in the ground state to the metastable state could be determined to a precision of $δR=1\cdot 10^{-11}$, unprecedented in the heavy atom regime. With a lifetime of about 130 days, the potential soft x-ray frequency reference at $ν=4.86\cdot 10^{16}\,\text{Hz}$ has a linewidth of only $Δν\approx 5\cdot 10^{-8}\,\text{Hz}$, and one of the highest electronic quality factor ($Q=\fracν{Δν}\approx 10^{24}$) ever seen in an experiment. Our low uncertainty enables searching for more HCI soft x-ray clock transitions, needed for promising precision studies of fundamental physics in a thus far unexplored frontier.

Cooling antihydrogen ions for the free-fall experiment GBAR

Laurent Hilico [1], Jean-Philippe Karr [1], Albane Douillet [1], Paul Indelicato [2], Sebastian Wolf [3], Ferdinand Schmidt Kaler [3]

Abstract

We discuss an experimental approach allowing to prepare antihydrogen atoms for the GBAR experiment. We study the feasibility of all necessary experimental steps: The capture of incoming $\bar{\rm H}^+$ ions at keV energies in a deep linear RF trap, sympathetic cooling by laser cooled Be$^+$ ions, transfer to a miniaturized trap and Raman sideband cooling of an ion pair to the motional ground state, and further reducing the momentum of the wavepacket by adiabatic opening of the trap. For each step, we point out the experimental challenges and discuss the efficiency and characteristic times, showing that capture and cooling are possible within a few seconds.

The Electrostatic Ion Beam Trap : a mass spectrometer of infinite mass range

Alexandre Vallette [1], Csilla Szabo Foster, Paul Indelicato

Abstract

We study the ions dynamics inside an Electrostatic Ion Beam Trap (EIBT) and show that the stability of the trapping is ruled by a Hill's equation. This unexpectedly demonstrates that an EIBT, in the reference frame of the ions works very similar to a quadrupole trap. The parallelism between these two kinds of traps is illustrated by comparing experimental and theoretical stability diagrams of the EIBT. The main difference with quadrupole traps is that the stability depends only on the ratio of the acceleration and trapping electrostatic potentials, not on the mass nor the charge of the ions. All kinds of ions can be trapped simultaneously and since parametric resonances are proportional to the square root of the charge/mass ratio the EIBT can be used as a mass spectrometer of infinite mass range.

Analytical study of electrostatic ion beam traps

Alexandre Vallette [1], Paul Indelicato

Abstract

The use of electrostatic ion beam traps require to set many potentials on the electrodes (ten in our case), making the tuning much more difficult than with quadrupole traps. In order to obtain the best trapping conditions, an analytical formula giving the electrostatic potential inside the trap is required. In this paper, we present a general method to calculate the analytical expression of the electrostatic potential in any axisymmetric set of electrodes. We use conformal mapping to simplify the geometry of the boundary. The calculation is then performed in a space of simple geometry. We show that this method, providing excellent accuracy, allows to obtain the potential on the axis as an analytic function of the potentials applied to the electrodes, thus leading to fast, accurate and efficient calculations. We conclude by presenting stability maps depending on the potentials that enabled us to find the good trapping conditions for oxygen 4+ at much higher energies than what has been achieved until now.

Relativistic correlation correction to the binding energies of the ground configuration of Beryllium-like, Neon-like, Magnesium-like and Argon-like ions

J. P. Santos [1,2,3], Gustavo C. Rodriges, José P. Marques, F. Parente [2,3], Jean-Paul Desclaux, Paul Indelicato

Abstract

Total electronic correlation correction to the binding energies of the isoelectronic series of Beryllium, Neon, Magnesium and Argon, are calculated in the framework of relativistic multiconfiguration Dirac-Fock method. Convergence of the correlation energies is studied as the active set of orbitals is increased. The Breit interaction is treated fully self-consistently. The final results can be used in the accurately determination of atomic masses from highly charged ions data obtained in Penning-trap experiments.

High Resolution He-like Argon And Sulfur Spectra From The PSI ECRIT

Martino Trassinelli, Sandor Biri, Stephane Boucard, Daniel S. Covita, Detlev Gotta, Bruno Leoni, Albert Hirtl, Paul Indelicato, Eric-Olivier Le Bigot, Joaquim M. F. Dos Santos, Leopold M. Simons, Lucas Stingelin, Joao F. C. A. Veloso, Alfred Wasser, Johann Zmeskal

Abstract

We present new results on the X-ray spectroscopy of multicharged argon, sulfur and chlorine obtained with the Electron Cyclotron Resonance Ion Trap (ECRIT) in operation at the Paul Scherrer Institut (Villigen, Switzerland). We used a Johann-type Bragg spectrometer with a spherically-bent crystal, with an energy resolution of about 0.4 eV. The ECRIT itself is of a hybrid type, with a superconducting split coil magnet, special iron inserts which provides the mirror field, and a permanent magnetic hexapole. The high frequency was provided by a 6.4 GHz microwave emitter. We obtained high intensity X-ray spectra of multicharged F-like to He-like argon, sulfur and chlorine with one 1s hole. In particular, we observed the $1s2s^{3}S_1 \to 1s^2^{1}S_0 M1$ and $1s2p^{3}P_2 \to 1s^2^{1}S_0 M2$ transitions in He-like argon, sulfur and chlorine with unprecedented statistics and resolution. The energies of the observed lines are being determined with good accuracy using the He-like M1 line as a reference.