Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

A multi-ion optical clock with $\mathbf{5 \times 10^{-19}}$ uncertainty

Melina Filzinger [1], Martin R. Steinel [1], Jian Jiang [1], Daniel Bennett [1,2], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler, Ekkehard Peik [1], Nils Huntemann [1]

Abstract

Today's most accurate clocks are based on laser spectroscopy of electronic transitions in single trapped ions and feature fractional frequency uncertainties below $1\times10^{-18}$. Scaling these systems to multiple, simultaneously interrogated ions reduces measurement times, driving recent advances in multi-ion clocks. However, maintaining state-of-the-art systematic uncertainties while increasing the number of ions remains a central challenge. Here, we report on a multi-ion optical atomic clock with a fractional frequency uncertainty of $5.3\times10^{-19}$ and up to 10 \Sr ions. Ion-resolved state detection enables minimization of position-dependent shifts, with residual effects suppressed below the $10^{-20}$-level. Clock operation with eight to ten ions reduces the measurement time by a factor of 4.8 compared to single-ion operation. A comparison with an established \Yb single-ion clock yields an unperturbed frequency ratio of $0.6926711632159660405(20)$, with a statistical uncertainty of $0.9\times10^{-18}$ and a combined uncertainty of $2.9\times 10^{-18}$. These results demonstrate robust multi-ion clock operation with reduced averaging time and state-of-the-art accuracy.

Benchmarking Dual-Polarization Silicon Nitride Photonic Integrated Circuits for Trapped-Ion Quantum Technologies

Carl-Frederik Grimpe [1,2,3], Anastasiia Lüßmann-Sorokina, Guochun Du [1], Pragya Sah [4,5], Steffen Sauer [1,2,3], Elena Jordan [1], Rijil Thomas [4], Pascal Gehrmann [2,3], Maksim Lipkin [4,5], Stephan Suckow [4], Max C. Lemme [4,5], Stefanie Kroker [1,2,3,6,7], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

Trapped ions are one of the most advanced platforms for quantum technologies, with applications ranging from quantum computing to precision timekeeping. A crucial step towards more compact and scalable systems involves integrating photonic integrated circuits (PICs) into surface ion traps to enable on-chip light delivery and optical addressing of individual ions. Currently, most implementations rely solely on transverse-electric (TE) mode grating couplers, where the emitted light is polarized in the plane of the chip. In this work, we design, fabricate and characterize silicon nitride (Si\(_3\)N\(_4\)) PIC components, including incoupling structures, splitters, and grating couplers that support both TE and transverse-magnetic (TM) modes with comparable optical losses. We benchmark the PIC at 760\,nm, which is a typical wavelength for Yb$^{+}$-applications. The fabricated grating couplers enable the outcoupling of collimated free-space beams for both polarizations, exhibiting distinct emission angles. This dual-polarization capability gives more flexibility in polarization control and expands the accessible optical design space for trapped-ion quantum technologies.

Scalable chip-based 3D ion traps

Elena Jordan [1,2], Malte Brinkmann [1], Alexandre Didier [1], Erik Jansson [1], Martin Steinel [1], Nils Huntemann [1], Hu Shao [1], Hendrik Siebeneich [3], Christof Wunderlich [3], Michael Johanning [3,1,4,5], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

Ion traps are used for a wide range of applications from metrology to quantum simulations and quantum information processing. Microfabricated chip-based 3D ion traps are scalable to store many ions for the realization of a large number of qubits, provide deep trapping potentials compared to surface traps, and very good shielding from external electric fields. In this work, we give an overview of our recent developments on chip-based 3D ion traps. Different types of chip materials, the integration of electronic filter components on-chip and compact electrical connections in vacuum are discussed. Further, based on finite element method (FEM) simulations, we discuss how integrating micro-optics in 3D ion traps is possible without disturbing the trapped ions.

Electric Field Distortions in Surface Ion Traps with Integrated Nanophotonics

Guochun Du [1], Elena Jordan [1,2,3], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

The integration of photonic components into surface ion traps provides a scalable approach for trapped-ion quantum computing, sensing, and metrology, enabling compact systems with enhanced stability and precision. However, the introduction of optical apertures in the trap electrodes can distort the trapping electric field. This can lead to excess micromotion (EMM) and ion displacement which degrade the performance of quantum logic operations and optical clocks. In this work, we systematically investigate the electric field distortion in a surface ion trap with integrated waveguides and grating couplers using Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations. We analyze methods to reduce these distortions by exploiting symmetries and transparent conductive oxide materials.

Design of an aluminum nitride based electro-optic phase modulator and photonic switch for next generation scalable photonic integrated circuits

Suat Icli [1], Rangana Banerjee Chaudhuri [1], Elena Jordan [1], Fatemeh Salahshoori [1], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

Electro-optic modulators are fundamental components in atomic physics experiments, including trapped-ion systems used in precision metrology and quantum computing. To enable scalable photonic integration, we design and analyze an integrated photonic electro-optic phase modulator and switch at 411 nm for ytterbium ($Yb^{+}$) ions using aluminum nitride (AlN) waveguides. We employ finite element method (FEM) simulations to optimize optical confinement, RF impedance matching, and electro-optic modulation efficiency. The phase modulator achieves a DC $V_πL$ of 178 V cm for TE polarization. The photonic switch, designed with a push-pull electrode configuration, demonstrates a $V_πL$ of 24 V cm, enabling efficient operation at lower voltages. These results highlight AlN as a candidate for ultraviolet photonic integrated circuits, facilitating high-speed optical modulation for trapped-ion applications.

Indium tin oxide combined with anti-reflective coatings with high transmittance for wavelengths < 400 nm

Erik Jansson [1], Volker Scheuer [2], Elena Jordan [1], Konstantina Kostourou [2,1,3,4], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

The transparent and conductive properties of indium tin oxide (ITO) thin films, make them an attractive coating for optically integrated ion traps. However, the relatively low transmittance for wavelengths $<$ 400 nm, high scattering and high production temperature limits the usability in trapped-ion-based quantum technologies. Here we present ITO coatings and a combined ITO + anti-reflective (AR) coating system optimized for an ion trap applied using ion beam sputtering (IBS). The coatings feature a high transmittance for wavelengths $<$ 400 nm and additional wavelengths up to 1000 nm, low scattering and low production temperature $<$ 150 $^{\circ}$C. The transmission, reflection and absorption spectra are simulated and the resistance, transmittance and scattering at 370 nm are measured for different ITO coating thicknesses and the ITO + AR coating system. For the ITO + AR coating system a resistance of 115 $\pm$ 5 $Ω/\Box$, transmittance of 80$\%$ and scattering of 0.012 $\pm$ 0.002$\%$ at 370 nm is achieved.

Deterministic preparation of a dual-species two-ion crystal

Maximilian J. Zawierucha [1,2], Till Rehmert [1,2], Jonas Keller [1,2], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler, Piet O. Schmidt [1,2], Fabian Wolf [1]

Abstract

The demand for efficient preparation methods for dual-species ion crystals is rapidly expanding across quantum technology and fundamental physics applications with trapped ions. We present a deterministic and efficient technique to produce such crystals, utilizing the segmented structure of a linear Paul trap. By precisely tailoring the trapping potentials, we can split, move, and discard parts of an ion chain. This process is automated in a sequence that converts a larger ion sample into the desired configuration. A critical component of our approach is the accurate identification of crystal constituents. This is achieved by matching the measured positions of fluorescing ions against theoretical expectations for larger crystals, thus facilitating the detection of non-fluorescing ions and enabling accurate ion counting. We demonstrate that our method reliably produces two-ion crystals within minutes. These results represent a significant advance in the production of two-species ion crystals with applications ranging from quantum logic spectroscopy and optical clocks to quantum computing and simulation with trapped ions.

Sideband thermometry of ion crystals

Ivan Vybornyi [1], Laura S. Dreissen [2,3], Dominik Kiesenhofer [4,5], Helene Hainzer [4,5], Matthias Bock [4,5], Tuomas Ollikainen [4,5], Daniel Vadlejch [2], Christian F. Roos [4,5,2,6], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler, Klemens Hammerer [1]

Abstract

Coulomb crystals of cold trapped ions are a leading platform for the realisation of quantum processors and quantum simulations and, in quantum metrology, for the construction of optical atomic clocks and for fundamental tests of the Standard Model. For these applications, it is not only essential to cool the ion crystal in all its degrees of freedom down to the quantum ground state, but also to be able to determine its temperature with a high accuracy. However, when a large ground-state cooled crystal is interrogated for thermometry, complex many-body interactions take place, making it challenging to accurately estimate the temperature with established techniques. In this work we present a new thermometry method tailored for ion crystals. The method is applicable to all normal modes of motion and does not suffer from a computational bottleneck when applied to large ion crystals. We test the temperature estimate with two experiments, namely with a 1D linear chain of 4 ions and a 2D crystal of 19 ions and verify the results, where possible, using other methods. The results show that the new method is an accurate and efficient tool for thermometry of ion crystals.

Excitation of forbidden electronic transitions in atoms by Hermite-Gaussian modes

Anton A. Peshkov, Elena Jordan, Markus Kromrey, Karan K. Mehta, Tanja E. Mehlstäubler, Andrey Surzhykov [1]

Abstract

Photoexcitation of trapped ions by Hermite-Gaussian (HG) modes from guided beam structures is proposed and investigated theoretically. In particular, simple analytical expressions for the Rabi frequencies of induced atomic transitions are derived that depend both on the parameters of HG beams and on the geometry of an experiment. By using these general expressions, we investigate the $^{2}S_{1/2} \to \; ^{2}F_{7/2}$ electric octupole (E3) transition in an Yb$^{+}$ ion, localized in the low--intensity center of the HG$_{10}$ and HG$_{01}$ beams. We show how the corresponding Rabi frequency can be enhanced by properly choosing the polarization of incident light and the orientation of an external magnetic field, which defines the quantization axis of a target ion. The calculations, performed for experimentally feasible beam parameters, indicate that the achieved Rabi frequencies can be comparable or even higher than those observed for the conventional Laguerre-Gaussian (LG) modes. Since HG-like modes can be relatively straightforwardly generated with high purity and stability from integrated photonics, our results suggest that they may form a novel tool for investigating highly-forbidden atomic transitions.

Improved bounds on Lorentz violation from composite-pulse Ramsey spectroscopy in a trapped ion

Laura S. Dreissen [1], Chih-Han Yeh [1,2], Henning A. Fürst, Kai C. Grensemann [1,2], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

In attempts to unify the four known fundamental forces in a single quantum-consistent theory, it is suggested that Lorentz symmetry may be broken at the Planck scale. Here we search for Lorentz violation at the low-energy limit by comparing orthogonally oriented atomic orbitals in a Michelson-Morley-type experiment. We apply a robust radiofrequency composite pulse sequence in the $^2F_{7/2}$ manifold of an Yb$^+$ ion, extending the coherence time from 200 $μ$s to more than 1 s. In this manner, we fully exploit the high intrinsic susceptibility of the $^2F_{7/2}$ state and take advantage of its exceptionally long lifetime. We match the stability of the previous best Lorentz symmetry test nearly an order of magnitude faster and improve the constraints on the symmetry breaking coefficients to the 10$^{-21}$ level. These results represent the most stringent test of this type of Lorentz violation. The demonstrated method can be further extended to ion Coulomb crystals.

Finite temperature spectrum at the symmetry-breaking linear-zigzag transition

Jan Kiethe [1], Lars Timm [2], Haggai Landa [3,4], Dimitri Kalincev [1], Giovanna Morigi [5,1,6], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

We investigate the normal mode spectrum of a trapped ion chain at the symmetry-breaking linear to zigzag transition and at finite temperatures. For this purpose we modulate the amplitude of the Doppler cooling laser in order to excite and measure mode oscillations. The expected mode softening at the critical point, a signature of the second-order transition, is not observed. Numerical simulations show that this is mainly due to the finite temperature of the chain. Inspection of the trajectories suggest that the thermal shifts of the normal-mode spectrum can be understood by the ions collectively jumping between the two ground state configurations of the symmetry broken phase. We develop an effective analytical model, which allows us to reproduce the low-frequency spectrum as a function of the temperature and close to the transition point. In this model the frequency shift of the soft mode is due to the anharmonic coupling with the high frequency modes of the spectrum, acting as an averaged effective thermal environment. Our study could prove important for implementing ground-state laser cooling close to the critical point.

Coherent excitation of the highly forbidden electric octupole transition in ${}^{172}$Yb$^+$

Henning A. Fürst, Chih-Han Yeh, Dimitri Kalincev, André P. Kulosa, Laura S. Dreissen, Richard Lange, Erik Benkler, Nils Huntemann, Ekkehard Peik, Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

We report on the first coherent excitation of the highly forbidden $^2S_{1/2}\rightarrow{}^2F_{7/2}$ electric octupole (E3) transition in a single trapped ${}^{172}$Yb$^+$ ion, an isotope without nuclear spin. Using the transition in ${}^{171}$Yb$^+$ as a reference, we determine the transition frequency to be $642\,116\,784\,950\,887.6(2.4)\,$Hz. We map out the magnetic field environment using the forbidden $^2S_{1/2} \rightarrow{}^2D_{5/2}$ electric quadrupole (E2) transition and determine its frequency to be $729\,476\,867\,027\,206.8(4.4)\,$Hz. Our results are a factor of $1\times10^5$ ($3\times10^{5}$) more accurate for the E2 (E3) transition compared to previous measurements. The results open up the way to search for new physics via precise isotope shift measurements and improved tests of local Lorentz invariance using the metastable $^2F_{7/2}$ state of Yb$^+$.

Guidelines for developing optical clocks with $10^{-18}$ fractional frequency uncertainty

Moustafa Abdel-Hafiz [1], Piotr Ablewski [2], Ali Al-Masoudi [1,3], Héctor Ã\udc81lvarez Martínez, Petr Balling [4], Geoffrey Barwood [5], Erik Benkler [1], Marcin Bober [2], Mateusz Borkowski [2], William Bowden [5,2], Roman CiuryÅ‚o, Hubert Cybulski [2], Alexandre Didier [1,4], Miroslav Doležal, Sören Dörscher, Stephan Falke [1], Rachel M. Godun [5], Ramiz Hamid [6], Ian R. Hill [5], Richard Hobson [5], Nils Huntemann [1], Yann Le Coq [7], Rodolphe Le Targat [7], Thomas Legero [1], Thomas Lindvall [8], Christian Lisdat [1,7], Jérôme Lodewyck, Helen S. Margolis [5,1], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler, Ekkehard Peik [1], Lennart Pelzer [1,9], Marco Pizzocaro [10], Benjamin Rauf [10], Antoine Rolland [5], Nils Scharnhorst [1,9], Marco Schioppo [5], Piet O. Schmidt [1,9], Roman Schwarz [1,6,11], ÇaÄŸrı Åženel, Nicolas Spethmann [1], Uwe Sterr [1], Christian Tamm [1], Jan W. Thomsen [12], Alvise Vianello [5,2,8], MichaÅ‚ Zawada

Abstract

There has been tremendous progress in the performance of optical frequency standards since the first proposals to carry out precision spectroscopy on trapped, single ions in the 1970s. The estimated fractional frequency uncertainty of today's leading optical standards is currently in the $10^{-18}$ range, approximately two orders of magnitude better than that of the best caesium primary frequency standards. This exceptional accuracy and stability is resulting in a growing number of research groups developing optical clocks. While good review papers covering the topic already exist, more practical guidelines are needed as a complement. The purpose of this document is therefore to provide technical guidance for researchers starting in the field of optical clocks. The target audience includes national metrology institutes (NMIs) wanting to set up optical clocks (or subsystems thereof) and PhD students and postdocs entering the field. Another potential audience is academic groups with experience in atomic physics and atom or ion trapping, but with less experience of time and frequency metrology and optical clock requirements. These guidelines have arisen from the scope of the EMPIR project "Optical clocks with $1 \times 10^{-18}$ uncertainty" (OC18). Therefore, the examples are from European laboratories even though similar work is carried out all over the world. The goal of OC18 was to push the development of optical clocks by improving each of the necessary subsystems: ultrastable lasers, neutral-atom and single-ion traps, and interrogation techniques. This document shares the knowledge acquired by the OC18 project consortium and gives practical guidance on each of these aspects.

Fokker-Planck formalism approach to Kibble-Zurek scaling laws and non-equilibrium dynamics

Ricardo Puebla [1], Ramil Nigmatullin [2,3,1], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler, Martin. B. Plenio

Abstract

We study the non-equilibrium dynamics of second-order phase transitions in a simplified Ginzburg-Landau model using the Fokker-Planck formalism. In particular, we focus on deriving the Kibble-Zurek scaling laws that dictate the dependence of spatial correlations on the quench rate. In the limiting cases of overdamped and underdamped dynamics, the Fokker-Planck method confirms the theoretical predictions of the Kibble-Zurek scaling theory. The developed framework is computationally efficient, enables the prediction of finite-size scaling functions and is applicable to microscopic models as well as their hydrodynamic approximations. We demonstrate this extended range of applicability by analyzing the non-equilibrium linear to zigzag structural phase transition in ion Coulomb crystals confined in a trap with periodic boundary conditions.

Analysis of thermal radiation in ion traps for optical frequency standards

Miroslav Doležal, Petr Balling, Peter B R Nisbet-Jones, Steven A King, Jonathan M Jones, Hugh A Klein, Patrick Gill, Thomas Lindvall, Anders E Wallin, Mikko Merimaa, Christian Tamm, Christian Sanner, Nils Huntemann, Nils Scharnhorst, Ian D Leroux, Piet O Schmidt, Tobias Burgermeister, Tanja E Mehlstäubler, Ekkehard Peik

Abstract

In many of the high-precision optical frequency standards with trapped atoms or ions that are under development to date, the AC Stark shift induced by thermal radiation leads to a major contribution to the systematic uncertainty. We present an analysis of the inhomogeneous thermal environment experienced by ions in various types of ion traps. Finite element models which allow the determination of the temperature of the trap structure and the temperature of the radiation were developed for 5 ion trap designs, including operational traps at PTB and NPL and further optimized designs. Models were refined based on comparison with infrared camera measurement until an agreement of better than 10% of the measured temperature rise at critical test points was reached. The effective temperature rises of the radiation seen by the ion range from 0.8 K to 2.1 K at standard working conditions. The corresponding fractional frequency shift uncertainties resulting from the uncertainty in temperature are in the 10-18 range for optical clocks based on the Sr+ and Yb+ E2 transitions, and even lower for Yb+ E3, In+ and Al+. Issues critical for heating of the trap structure and its predictability were identified and design recommendations developed.

Structural phase transitions and topological defects in ion Coulomb crystals

Heather L. Partner, Ramil Nigmatullin, Tobias Burgermeister, Jonas Keller, Karsten Pyka, Martin B. Plenio, Alex Retzker [1], Wojciech H. Zurek [1], Adolfo del Campo [1], Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

We use laser-cooled ion Coulomb crystals in the well-controlled environment of a harmonic radiofrequency ion trap to investigate phase transitions and defect formation. Topological defects in ion Coulomb crystals (kinks) have been recently proposed for studies of nonlinear physics with solitons and as carriers of quantum information. Defects form when a symmetry breaking phase transition is crossed nonadiabatically. For a second order phase transition, the Kibble-Zurek mechanism predicts that the formation of these defects follows a power law scaling in the rate of the transition. We demonstrate a scaling of defect density and describe kink dynamics and stability. We further discuss the implementation of mass defects and electric fields as first steps toward controlled kink preparation and manipulation.

Symmetry Breaking and Topological Defect Formation in Ion Coulomb Crystals

Karsten Pyka, Jonas Keller, Heather L. Partner, Ramil Nigmatullin, Tobias Burgermeister, David-M. Meier, Kristijan Kuhlmann, Alex Retzker, Martin B. Plenio, Wojciech H. Zurek, Adolfo del Campo, Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

Symmetry breaking phase transitions play an important role in nature. When a system traverses such a transition at a finite rate, its causally disconnected regions choose the new broken symmetry state independently. Where such local choices are incompatible, defects will form with densities predicted to follow a power law scaling in the rate of the transition. The importance of this Kibble-Zurek mechanism (KZM) ranges from cosmology to condensed matter [1-4]. In previous tests in homogeneous systems, defect formation was seen, but weak dependence on the transition rate and limited control of external parameters so far prevented tests of KZM scaling. As recently predicted [5-9], in inhomogeneous systems propagation of the critical front enhances the role of causality and steepens scaling of defect density with the transition rate. We use ion Coulomb crystals in a harmonic trap to demonstrate, for the first time, scaling of the number of topological defects with the transition rate - the central prediction of KZM - in a well-controlled environment.

A high-precision rf trap with minimized micromotion for an In+ multiple-ion clock

Karsten Pyka, Norbert Herschbach, Jonas Keller, Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

We present an experiment to characterize our new linear ion trap designed for the operation of a many-ion optical clock using 115-In^+ as clock ions. For the characterization of the trap as well as the sympathetic cooling of the clock ions we use 172-Yb^+. The trap design has been derived from finite element method (FEM) calculations and a first prototype based on glass-reinforced thermoset laminates was built. This paper details on the trap manufacturing process and micromotion measurement. Excess micromotion is measured using photon-correlation spectroscopy with a resolution of 1.1nm in motional amplitude, and residual axial rf fields in this trap are compared to FEM calculations. With this method, we demonstrate a sensitivity to systematic clock shifts due to excess micromotion of |(Δν/ν)| = 8.5x10^-20. Based on the measurement of axial rf fields of our trap, we estimate a number of twelve ions that can be stored per trapping segment and used as an optical frequency standard with a fractional inaccuracy of \leq 1x10^-18 due to micromotion.

Linear Paul trap design for an optical clock with Coulomb crystals

Norbert Herschbach, Karsten Pyka, Jonas Keller, Tanja E. Mehlstäubler

Abstract

We report on the design of a segmented linear Paul trap for optical clock applications using trapped ion Coulomb crystals. For an optical clock with an improved short-term stability and a fractional frequency uncertainty of 10^-18, we propose 115In+ ions sympathetically cooled by 172Yb+. We discuss the systematic frequency shifts of such a frequency standard. In particular, we elaborate on high precision calculations of the electric radiofrequency field of the ion trap using the finite element method. These calculations are used to find a scalable design with minimized excess micromotion of the ions at a level at which the corresponding second- order Doppler shift contributes less than 10^-18 to the relative uncertainty of the frequency standard.